Miggle
FUCK UBISOFT
+1,411|6939|FUCK UBISOFT

K, so we have a console game reviews thread, why not a PC game review thread?

give any PC game a score from 1 to 10 (1 being terrible, 10 being godlike)

Reviews:
GAMEREVIEWSSCORE
Dungeon Keeper 2110
Half Life39.9
EVE: Online19.5
Flight Simulator X19.5
Half Life 2: Episode 229.5
Trackmania Nations29.5
Team Fortress 299.4
Half Life 249.3
System Shock 229.3
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas49.2
Alien vs Predator 219
Counter Strike 1.619
Deus Ex19
Day of Defeat: Source39
Supreme Commander19
Thief 219
Portal98.8
Battlefield 278.6
Call of Duty18.5
Garry's Mod28.5
Roller Coaster Tycoon 3 Platinum18.5
Stronghold18.5
World in Conflict28.5
Battlefield 194248.4
Company of Heroes28.2
TES4: Oblivion38.1
Battlefield 2: Special Forces38
Black and White 218
Command and Conquer 338
Half Life 2: Episode 138
Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Vegas 218
Crysis37.9
Audiosurf37.8
Sins of a Solar Empire27.5
The Movies17.5
Battlefield 214267.3
Gears of War17.1
Need For Speed: ProStreet17
Call of Duty 446.7
IL-2 Sturmovik: 194616
Combat Arms15
Counter Strike: Condition Zero15
Bioshock34.7


mods if you could help me keep this up to date that would be a huge help.

last updated

Last edited by Miggle (2008-08-21 09:14:05)

https://i.imgur.com/86fodNE.png
kptk92
u
+972|6605|tc_london
Team Fortress 2 - 10/10
Day of Defeat: Source - 9/10
Counter Strike: Source - 7/10
Audiosurf - 7/10
Garrys Mod - 7/10
Battlefield 2 - 8/10
Battlefield 2142 - 7/10
Battlefield 1942 - 7/10
Call of Duty 4 - 3/10
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas - 9/10

Last edited by kptk92 (2008-08-18 13:06:57)

Spidery_Yoda
Member
+399|6467
Team Fortress 2 - 10
Half Life - 10
Half Life 2 - 9.5
Portal - 9
Battlefield 2 - 9
Crysis - 9
Battlefield 2142 - 8
CnC3 - 8
CS:S - 8

I'll probably think of more later.
Bevo
Nah
+718|6718|Austin, Texas
TF2 9/10
HL2 9.5/10
Portal 10/10
BF2 9/10
2142 7/10
COD4 9/10
Mutantbear
Semi Constructive Criticism
+1,431|6162|London, England

Team Fortress 2 - 10/10
Day of Defeat: Source - 9/10
Counter Strike: Source - 5/10
Audiosurf - 7/10
Battlefield 2 - 8/10
Call of Duty 4 - 8/10
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas - 9/10
Portal - 9/10
Bioshock - 3/10
Half Life 2 - 10/10
ep 1 - 7/10
ep 2 - 10/10
Crysis - 5/10
_______________________________________________________________________________________________ https://i.imgur.com/Xj4f2.png
Winston_Churchill
Bazinga!
+521|6936|Toronto | Canada

Crysis - 8
TES4: Oblivion - 10
Battlefield 2 - 8
Portal - 9
Command and Conquer 3 - 9
Battlefield 2142 - 8
Audiosurf - 9
Battlefield 1942 - 10
Fat_Swinub
jaff
+125|6632
TF2 - 8
Bioshock - 5
COD4 - 5
GTA: SA - 10
BF2 - 9
Oblivion - 7
BF2142 - 7
Portal - 7
Bevo
Nah
+718|6718|Austin, Texas
eveo - 9.5
wow (demo ) - 9

Last edited by MadKatter (2008-08-18 13:24:49)

Titch2349
iz me!
+358|6549|uk

Gtasa = 9/10
Bf1942 = 8/10
Bf2142 = 6/10
Bf2 = 10/10

Edit- Screw the forums and its auto un-capitalisation

Last edited by Titch2349 (2008-08-18 13:40:18)

Ryan
Member
+1,230|7040|Alberta, Canada

BF2 = 7/10
BF2:SF = 8/10
Trackmania = 9.5/10
Call of Duty 4 = 9/10
Sins of a Solar Empire = 6/10
Combat Arms = 5/10
Need for Speed: ProStreet = 7/10
World in Combat = 9/10
Company of Heroes = 7/10
Mutantbear
Semi Constructive Criticism
+1,431|6162|London, England

Trackmania - 10/10 (I might buy the full version)
_______________________________________________________________________________________________ https://i.imgur.com/Xj4f2.png
Tetn1s
Member
+59|6839|Los Angeles
tf2 9.8
cod4 5.0
hl2 8.5
bf2 9.8
gow 7.1
crysis 8.0
Miggle
FUCK UBISOFT
+1,411|6939|FUCK UBISOFT

I'm surprised bioshock is doing so bad...

I thought it was ok. Just not as good as System Shock 2.

Last edited by Miggle (2008-08-18 14:08:24)

https://i.imgur.com/86fodNE.png
Spidery_Yoda
Member
+399|6467
I thought Bioshock was great. But I didn't play the entire thing so i cant rate it.
Titch2349
iz me!
+358|6549|uk

Mutantsteak wrote:

Trackmania - 10/10 (I might buy the full version)
Srly dude, its a waste of money

Trackmania: 10/10 also. (and its free!!!)
Vilham
Say wat!?
+580|6963|UK
You guys give perfect 10s and 9s far too easily.

Out of the games up there an few ill add myself:

Half Life    9.5
Half Life 2: Episode 2 8.5
System Shock 2    8.5
Team Fortress 2    8
Half Life 2    8.5
World in Conflict    8
Day of Defeat: Source    8
Battlefield 2    8
TES4: Oblivion    2    7
Portal    9
Command and Conquer 3    7
Battlefield 1942    8.5
Battlefield 2: Special Forces    8
Battlefield 2142    8
Company of Heroes    9
Half Life 2: Episode 1    8.5
Counter Strike: Source    8
Call of Duty 4    8
Sins of a Solar Empire    9
Bioshock 6
Dungeon Keeper 2 1 million lol nah 10 really.
Deus Ex 9
AvP2 9
Supreme Commander 9
Thief 2 9
Stronghold 8.5
Black and White 2 8
Call of Duty 8.5
Poseidon
Fudgepack DeQueef
+3,253|6735|Long Island, New York
Crysis - 9/10
Company of Heroes - 8.5/10
Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Vegas 2 - 8/10
Flight Simulator X - 9.5/10
Battlefield 2 - 8/10
BF2: Special Forces - 8/10
BF2142 - 7/10
CounterStrike: Source - 8/10
Day of Defeat: Source - 9.5/10
The Movies - 7.5/10
Team Fortress 2 - 10/10
Half Life - 10/10
Half Life 2 - 10/10
Half Life 2: Episode 1 - 8.5/10
Half Life 2: Episode 2 - 10/10
Portal - 10/10
CounterStrike 1.6 - 9/10
CounterStrike: Condition Zero - 5/10
Trackmania - 9/10
IL-2 Sturmovik: 1946 - 6/10
Roller Coaster Tycoon 3 Platinum - 8.5/10
Audiosurf - 8/10
Garry's Mod - 10/10

Last edited by Poseidon (2008-08-18 15:51:11)

sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|6954|Argentina
HL - 10
HL2 - 8
Portal - 9
HL2: Ep.1 - 7
HL2: Ep.2 - 9
TF2 - 10
CS 1.6 - 9
CS Source - 8
BF2 - 10
BFSF - 8
BF2142 - 5
COH - 9
Crysis - 6
COD4 - 9
Warcraft III: Reign of Chaos - 10
Warcraft III: Frozen Throne - 9

To be updated.

Last edited by sergeriver (2008-08-21 04:48:03)

sportsman11-2cool4u
We can be those mistakes!
+98|6524|USA Biznatch!
BF2 - 10/10
BF2 SF - 8.5/10
BF2142 - 5/10
CSS - 9/10
HL - 10/10
Portal - 8.5/10 (Too short =S)
Garry's Mod - 9/10
CoD - 10/10
Prey - 7/10

Yeah I won't go into the old games I have =P.
firebolt5
Member
+114|6352
Call of Duty - 9/10
Call of Duty:  United Offensive - 9/10
Silent Storm - 8.9/10
Silent Storm Sentinels - 9/10
nukchebi0
Пушкин, наше всё
+387|6521|New Haven, CT
Team Fortress 2 - 9
Half Life 2 - 10
World in Conflict - 9
Battlefield 2 - 9
TES4: Oblivion - 9
Portal - 10
Command and Conquer 3 - 8
Battlefield 1942 - 9
Battlefield 2: Special Forces - 9
Battlefield 2142 - 7
Counter Strike: Source - 4
Call of Duty 4 - 9
Sins of a Solar Empire - 8
Bioshock - 9
LOMAC - 9

Wow, I guess I like a lot of games.
acEofspadEs6313
Shiny! Let's be bad guys.
+102|6889|NAS Jacksonville, Florida
Battleground Europe --- 10
Theater of War --- 6
Age of Conan --- 7
Armed Assault: Combat Operations --- 5
IL-2: Sturmovik --- 8
Call of Duty 4 --- 6
Supreme Commander: Forged Alliance --- 8
Battlefield 2 --- 6
Hearts of Iron II: Armageddon --- 7
Battlefield 1942 --- 9
Battlefield Vietnam --- 5
Silent Hunter III --- 7
SharkyMcshark
I'll take two
+132|6982|Perth, Western Australia
Trackmania Nations --- 8
Team Fortress 2    --- 4
Half Life 2 --- 7
World in Conflict --- 7.5
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas --- 9.5   
Battlefield 2 --- 9.6
Portal    --- 8
Battlefield 2: Special Forces --- 8
Half Life 2: Episode 1 --- 7
Call of Duty 4
Longbow
Member
+163|6844|Odessa, Ukraine
HL - 7
HL2 - 7
HL2: Ep.1 - 7
CS 1.6 - 1
CS Source - 2
BF1942 - 10
BF:V - 9
BF2 - 10
BFSF - 7
BF2142 - 9
Crysis - 1
Mass Effect - 8
TES3 Morrowind - 10
TES4 Oblivion    - 9
GTA:SA - 10
COD4 - 5
NFS:UG1 - 10
NFS:UG2 - 9.5
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. : SoC - 10
Overlord - 9.5
Space Rangers 2 - 10
Empire Earth - 9.7
Empire Earth III - 1
C&C - 10
RA1 - 10
RA2 - 8
C&C Generals - 9
C&C Generals : Zero Hour - 10
Battlestations Midway - 9.7
Commie Killer
Member
+192|6584
BF1942 and Expansions- 9.5/10
BFV- 8.5/10
BF2 and Expansions-9.5/10
Medal of Honor Allied Assault and Expansions- 9.9/10
Medal of Honor Pacific Assault- 8.0/10
Entire Half Life series- 10/10
CS:S- 9.5/10
DoD:S- 9/10
FarCry- 9/10
Crysis- 8.5/10
CoD and Expansions- 9.8/10
CoD2- 9/10
CoD4- 9.9/10
Ghost Recon Series- 9/10

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2024 Jeff Minard