Which would you choose? 2GB Dual Channel or 3GB total?

2006-05-18 14:26:21

#1

JE3146: Member; +109|6562|Oregon

I just got a 2GB (2x1GB) matched pair of Corsair XMSC2pl RAM

I currently have 1GB(2x512MB) Corsair ValueRam

Should I go with 3GB using up my 4 slots? or 2GB of LL RAM in Dual Channel?

Which would be the smarter move?

2006-05-18 14:27:45

#2

notorious: Nay vee, bay bee.; +1,396|6738|The United Center

go with 2GB dual channelled.

...then tape the extra ram to your motherboard.

2006-05-18 14:28:44

#3

JE3146: Member; +109|6562|Oregon

ThomasMorgan wrote:
go with 2GB dual channelled.

...then tape the extra ram to your motherboard.

I'll just stick it in my gf's comp. She'll appreciate the boost.

Thanks for the advice. +1 to you.

2006-05-18 14:29:38

#4

liquidat0r: wtf.; +2,223|6618|UK

Strange i guess but i think you'll find that 2Gb is the better option.

Also if you want to upgrade again you have spare slots

Last edited by liquidat0r (2006-05-18 14:33:08)

2006-05-18 14:32:29

#5

vjs: Member; +19|6762

I'd certainly go with only the 2G in dual channel, you can get tighter timings with two sticks in addition those 2G sticks look quite a bit better as well.

Congrats and let us know how much of a difference you see.

2006-05-18 15:34:31

#6

Croak: Member; +11|6796|San Marcos, CA

Ditto on the 2g vote...tighter timings, (especially 1t command rate) and dual channel will have a bigger impact than another gig of RAM. It's not like the jump from 1g to 2g.

2006-05-18 16:03:37

#7

[FC]bigE: Member; +7|6660|Akron, OH

I agree with everyone on the 2gig vote. I've tried 3gig and it really didn't make an improvement except during video editing where I avoided writing to the HD as much, making the performance loss from dual channel unnoticable. I've since moved teh extra gig to another machine and am much happier gaming.

2006-05-19 16:07:05

#8

Viper007Bond: Moderator Emeritus; +236|6797|Portland, OR, USA

I can only use all of my 2 gigs if I actually try and use it all, so go with the dual channel.

https://bf3s.com/sigs/044900892044e7fc95e599e832a086ae9bcd7efb.png

2006-05-19 16:14:24

#9

JE3146: Member; +109|6562|Oregon

Went with the 2GB option, but unfortunately after some difficulties, I haven't been able to test out BF2....

working out the issues with my soundcard right now...

http://forums.bf2s.com/viewtopic.php?id=24843

2006-05-20 12:18:33

#10

JE3146: Member; +109|6562|Oregon

vjs wrote:
Congrats and let us know how much of a difference you see.

Incredible difference. 30 seconds of stutter on high textures went down to less than 1 second of stutter. Load times are 5 times faster. Was able to max out all my settings without any AA, which I'm gonna try that tonight for kicks. Graphics are incredible, smooth as hell gameplay. Put life back into my dated comp. I'm beginning to think processor speeds are overrated though. My 2800+ Barton is keeping up with this easily. And that is a very dated processor.

2006-05-20 12:22:00

#11

=TH=[Eleanor]-NL-: The Karma Collector!; +233|6682|The Netherlands

Wow good job, lol I got a 2800+ as well, not a Barton I guess, can't remember the name of mine though...

2006-05-20 12:28:19

#12

JE3146: Member; +109|6562|Oregon

=TH=[Eleanor]-NL- wrote:
Wow good job, lol I got a 2800+ as well, not a Barton I guess, can't remember the name of mine though...

Well, I got a 6800GS graphics card as well, on top of the new RAM.

1 Gig Value RAM to 2GB good stuff

FX5900 to 6800GS

Settings went from ALL LOW to ALL HIGH.

2006-05-20 12:30:13

#13

=TH=[Eleanor]-NL-: The Karma Collector!; +233|6682|The Netherlands

Nah I still have my Radeon 9700 Pro with 1 gig in dual channel (2x512). Enough for medium detail on 1280*1024...

2006-05-20 12:30:49

#14

Jack Bauer: WWJD - What Would Jack Do; +26|6545

JE3146 wrote:
ThomasMorgan wrote:
go with 2GB dual channelled.

...then tape the extra ram to your motherboard.
I'll just stick it in my gf's comp. She'll appreciate the boost.

Thanks for the advice. +1 to you.

Good call.

BF2S Forums Which would you choose? 2GB Dual Channel or 3GB total?

ThomasMorgan wrote:

vjs wrote:

=TH=[Eleanor]-NL- wrote:

JE3146 wrote:

ThomasMorgan wrote:

Board footer