TheAussieReaper wrote:
Comparing the poor Pakistani military intelligence isn't exactly fair when you look at the current US intelligence shortcomings. Republicans will blame it on Clinton cutting spending, Dems blame it on the poor running and handling of the separate intelligence agencies, etc. And it's pretty clear that the Pakistan intelligence agencies don't have anything near as sophisticated as that.
No, it's not that the 'poor Pakistani intelligence' can't compare to the US intelligence assets.. it's that
given good intel on exact locations of bad guys, they can't be bothered to do a damn thing about it. They're inept, corrupt, two-faced, and so riddled with everyone else's intelligence services it's not funny. You tell the Pakistanis where a bad guy is, you have a 50/50 chance of having just warned said bad guy you know where he is.
TheAussieReaper wrote:
I do think that the US requesting free travel into Pakistan, guns blazing is just the recipe for disaster. It only takes one village to be raided by US troops on Pakistani territory and you would be starting a war. It's that simple. The request that US troops avoid crossing the border isn't an unreasonable one.
You're telling me you have never seen just how precise the US military can be, when they want a specific target taken out whilst leaving the surrounding area untouched?
What you're talking about ('guns blazing', ' raiding villages') sounds more like an Oliver Stone vietnam movie - and nothing like the modern US military.
TheAussieReaper wrote:
If terrorists flee into Pakistan and cross the border, it's becomes Pakistans problem. They will have to deal with it as best they can. But you cant expect Iraq insurgents to be chased by the US into Afghanistan, then fighting with Al Qaeda, both groups chased into Pakistan and the US having free reign to hit potential targets with gunships and airstrikes on a free and sovereign nations soil.
The problem is that the Pakistanis are
not dealing with the problem. For 30 years, they've been soaking up Dollars in US military aid, and generally doing 'fuckall' with it. For being a US ally, they're being remarkably helpful in providing a safe harbor for the
other side.