Poll

Should the death penalty be banned

Yes. Who are we to judge20%20% - 53
No. You get what you deserve70%70% - 184
Undecided. Still thinking on that one9%9% - 24
Total: 261
UnknownRanger
Squirrels, natures little speedbump.
+610|6770|Cali

Hurricane wrote:

If the person is 100% guilty, all the proof points to him... then it should be allowed. Just make it more efficient. If the guy definitely did it, then give the verdict and sentencing and then take him to the prison house, give him his last meal, and then just kill him. Honestly, this dude took 34 minutes to die? Wouldn't happen with a swift piece of shaped metal to the head.

This is the pure irony of the death sentence: it's supposed to keep the most dangerous people off the face of the earth, and yet it takes up to 30 years for the guy to actually be removed. During which not only could he escape, but the government spends boatloads of cash on keeping him fed, housed, entertained, and handled humanely.

Also, KEIOS, I see your point but in the USA we were founded with this little thing called Seperation of State and Church. Maybe I'm ignorant but that means the Church doesn't control the government, and the government should not let the Church influence their decisions. This evidently has been bent as much as it can be these past few presidencies, but it's still there. Hell maybe it isn't even an amendment or written in the Constitution (I'm rusty on my US history...) but if it is, then we shouldn't let religious beliefs influence our decision making process.
^          ^
Great explanation m8.
IRONCHEF
Member
+385|6916|Northern California

The_Shipbuilder wrote:

Commie Killer wrote:

The_Shipbuilder wrote:


Do Christians believe that those crimes deserve the death penalty?

If not, why not?
Because we have advanced 2,000 years, even though religion is stupid, and this topic has already become to religious, I dont think anyone believes that those things deserve death.
Thanks, but again, I'm interested to hear from Christians. Yes, 2,000 years have passed, but does time dilute the direct instructions of God to Moses?

Is there a statute of limitations on God's word?

If not, why SHOULDN'T real Christians kill adulterers, gays, people who swear at their parents, or women who have sex before marriage?
Christians don't kill for those things because they are not Christian teachings.  They are Jewish teachings.  There's this thing called Sermon on the Mount which pretty much direct Christians away from revenge, killing for equality, and even forgiving.  But of course it isn't something that can be used against Christians so it's ignored and Songs of Solomon and Mosaic law is quoted constantly..ignorantly and completely out of context.
Ajax_the_Great1
Dropped on request
+206|7071

Spearhead wrote:

Ajax_the_Great1 wrote:

Spearhead wrote:


The country as a whole is becoming F'ed up....... it's not just the death penalty, there are many other things that lots of people aren't happy about.

But, to sum it up in one sentence, it's just the growing "asshole" type attitude Americans are having more and more these days.
The assholes in this country are the ones being put in prison and executed. You defend them and hate them at the same time?
lol

No, murderers are mentally unstable.  Well, most of them.  They are not necessarily "assholes".  They are just plain psychotic.  Unless that;s not what you meant.  If you advocate murdering assholes who haven't done anything, than good luck with that.

By "assholes", I mean people who believe that the USA is the best, we can kick any countries ass, the Mid-East hates us because "uh... they just hate us because of our freedom", increasing lack of respect for Muslims, increasing support by the Christian right to impose their beliefs on the rest of us, etc.

We will most likely never become a fascist state, but there are many disturbing parallels between the USA today, and Germany in the 1920's and 30's.
Mentally unstable? Psychotic? Unless you are mentally retarded you have no excuse for murder.

I just find it funny that you think society in America is going to the shitters but it just breaks your heart when massmurder jonny gets the chair.
Pug
UR father's brother's nephew's former roommate
+652|6967|Texas - Bigger than France

Spearhead wrote:

Ajax_the_Great1 wrote:

Spearhead wrote:


The country as a whole is becoming F'ed up....... it's not just the death penalty, there are many other things that lots of people aren't happy about.

But, to sum it up in one sentence, it's just the growing "asshole" type attitude Americans are having more and more these days.
The assholes in this country are the ones being put in prison and executed. You defend them and hate them at the same time?
lol

No, murderers are mentally unstable.  Well, most of them.  They are not necessarily "assholes".  They are just plain psychotic.  Unless that;s not what you meant.  If you advocate murdering assholes who haven't done anything, than good luck with that.

By "assholes", I mean people who believe that the USA is the best, we can kick any countries ass, the Mid-East hates us because "uh... they just hate us because of our freedom", increasing lack of respect for Muslims, increasing support by the Christian right to impose their beliefs on the rest of us, etc.

We will most likely never become a fascist state, but there are many disturbing parallels between the USA today, and Germany in the 1920's and 30's.
Good Christ...have you looked at the propaganda you are spewing?

I'm interpreting the meaning of the above that if you are Christian and American, you are more likely to believe "USA is best, we can kick any country's ass, Middle East hates us for no reason, Islamic racists, and Nazis"?  And since this is a thread about the death penalty, that too.

So, did you know that Christians are less likely to support the death penalty, war & tolerance of other cultures when compared to other members of society for the same reasons you mentioned in this thread?

Supporting something you disagree with doesn't make them a Nazi.
QuadDamage@U
Member
+6|6767|Florida, USA
I did not read all 6 pages, but one point that was not mentioned is this...

The prisoner took 34 minutes to die FROM LETHAL INJECTION.  Death by lethal injection means they inject the convict with a lethal dose of Morphine (or similar) and wait for them to get sleepy, fall asleep, and die in their sleep.  In this case they missed the vein so the Morphine took longer than usuall to kick in. 

It's not like he spent 34 mins on the electric chair or hanging from a rope.  Honestly, I don't see what the big deal is.  He was already waiting on death row for years.  Another half hour of waiting shouldn't be a problem.
Spearhead
Gulf coast redneck hippy
+731|7115|Tampa Bay Florida

Pug wrote:

Good Christ...have you looked at the propaganda you are spewing?
lol, ?

Pug wrote:

I'm interpreting the meaning of the above that if you are Christian and American, you are more likely to believe "USA is best, we can kick any country's ass, Middle East hates us for no reason, Islamic racists, and Nazis"?  And since this is a thread about the death penalty, that too.
What the hell are you talking about?  I'm talking about the RADICAL right wing Christians who ARE imposing their beliefs on EVERY American in this country, and nationalist assholes such as the Bush administration who say "If you're not with us, you're against us". 

Pug wrote:

So, did you know that Christians are less likely to support the death penalty, war & tolerance of other cultures when compared to other members of society for the same reasons you mentioned in this thread?
Dude, chill, I'm not hating on Christians, I'm hating on Christians imposing their beliefs on the rest of us.  = Right wing radicals.

Pug wrote:

Supporting something you disagree with doesn't make them a Nazi.
Exactly, that's why I said we probably won't become fascist anyway.  I didn't fucking call them a Nazi, but if you look at the INCREASING level of hostility towards other countries, choosing security over freedom, and the increasing level of hypocrisy and bullshit expressed by both political parties, you CAN draw MANY disturbing PARALLELS between USA today and GERMANY in the 1930's.

Did I fucking call them Nazis?  No.  You misunderstoof what I meant, dude.  I'm not calling them Nazi's because they disagree with my own beliefs that no one cares about anyway, I'm saying there's PARALLELS in their fucking attitudes with the attitudes of other fascist states, including the Nazis before the buildup of World War 2.
Spearhead
Gulf coast redneck hippy
+731|7115|Tampa Bay Florida

Ajax_the_Great1 wrote:

Mentally unstable? Psychotic? Unless you are mentally retarded you have no excuse for murder.

I just find it funny that you think society in America is going to the shitters but it just breaks your heart when massmurder jonny gets the chair.
lmfao

Yeah, I really cry when a massmurderer dies.  /sarcasm

I'm calling the system broken.  Not only are we the one of the only civilized countries to still execute people, the system is sick.

Did I fucking say I wanted murderers to be released?  Hell no.  I said spending a life in prison is more humane than a government actually killing its own people, plus, if I were convicted of murder, I'd guarantee you I'd want an easy way out ASAP instead of living till I'm 80 to die.

See, the problem with you, and your morals, is that you see the massmurderer as nothing more than a massmurderer.  You neglect the fact that 1. He's a human being, being held in custody, and 2. There's a possibility he might be innocent, especially if he wasa just involved in one murder.

K, no more flaming from me, people have proven that they can't comprehend what I mean, and saying anymore will just get everyone pissed.
Stingray24
Proud member of the vast right-wing conspiracy
+1,060|6870|The Land of Scott Walker

Spearhead wrote:

Dude, chill, I'm not hating on Christians, I'm hating on Christians imposing their beliefs on the rest of us.  = Right wing radicals.
Wait a sec, I'm a right wing radical Christian and I'm not imposing my beliefs on anyone.  I just tell people what I personally believe and they can take it or leave it.  I do vote, though.  If that's imposing my beliefs, so be it. 

I acknowledge that a murderer is still a human being and that he might be innocent.  With a massmurderer, however, there will be plenty of evidence to convict because of multiple victims.  With advances in DNA evidence it is less likely an innocent person will be convicted.  I can see you point with a person that's committed one murder and does not have a violent past.  Perhaps we could rehabilitate the person depending on the circumstances.  Example: I come home to find a guy broke in and is trying to force himself on my wife.  I beat the hell out of him and finish him off with my shotgun.  Crime of passion, I can be rehabilitated.  Mass murderer/serial killer?  I doubt it.
Titch2349
iz me!
+358|6777|uk

death  = death.

If you kill someone, you should get killed.

The murderer made people suffer. The person he murdered, people who unqillingly watched, the family, hundreds of people

Then when the murderer isnt dead inside 5 minutes people complain that the murderer suffered too much?

Ridiculous.

Aslong as they are 100% the murderer, then the death sentence is fine.
Pug
UR father's brother's nephew's former roommate
+652|6967|Texas - Bigger than France
Pug wrote:
Good Christ...have you looked at the propaganda you are spewing?

lol, ?

Thank you, I thought it was a nice touch.

Spearhead wrote:

What the hell are you talking about?  I'm talking about the RADICAL right wing Christians who ARE imposing their beliefs on EVERY American in this country, and nationalist assholes such as the Bush administration who say "If you're not with us, you're against us".
My misunderstanding then.  Sorry about that.  What I saw was questions from you re: Jesus says no, you say yes, so why?  And are you a hypocrit?  Followed up by a statement about how assholes are steamrolling all over your beliefs.  I don't see how US foreign policy is included in a debate about the death penalty.  Which is why the leap was made. 

The issues aren't are not intertwined - death penalty = state level issue.  Foreign policy = National issue.  So my interpretation is that by including "USA is best", Islamics should die, and Christian Right in the same sentence in a thread about the death penalty is that you believe these are one in the same.  My bad.

So I took it in the wrong way - you're saying here's one more thing that stinks about this country...there are so many of them...here's some more examples like it.

Pug wrote:

Supporting something you disagree with doesn't make them a Nazi.

Spearhead wrote:

Exactly, that's why I said we probably won't become fascist anyway.  I didn't fucking call them a Nazi, but if you look at the INCREASING level of hostility towards other countries, choosing security over freedom, and the increasing level of hypocrisy and bullshit expressed by both political parties, you CAN draw MANY disturbing PARALLELS between USA today and GERMANY in the 1930's.

Did I fucking call them Nazis?  No.  You misunderstoof what I meant, dude.  I'm not calling them Nazi's because they disagree with my own beliefs that no one cares about anyway, I'm saying there's PARALLELS in their fucking attitudes with the attitudes of other fascist states, including the Nazis before the buildup of World War 2.
So the current attitudes parallel fascism, and then citing Nazis as a good example?  Sounds like your splitting hairs.  Unfortunately, I still think that applies.

I hate the extremes right or left equally, BTW.  But I don't think it's dangerlously close to coming to fruition as you say it is.  And frankly, leaving town is stupid.  Stick around and fix the problem.  The death penalty is a tough issue - ultimate sin either equates to ultimate punishment or forgiveness.  It's not hard to imagine yourself as a member of the victim's family or in the shoes of the condemmed.  The justice system certainly has flaws, but you know, you got to have faith it works most of the time sorting it all out.  I personally believe its the right thing to do not because I go to church, but because its rationalized...its equal to the crime.

Until I see an argument that will trump the victim family's feelings that the killer shouldn't get the death penalty, I'll support the death penalty.
Ajax_the_Great1
Dropped on request
+206|7071

Spearhead wrote:

Ajax_the_Great1 wrote:

Mentally unstable? Psychotic? Unless you are mentally retarded you have no excuse for murder.

I just find it funny that you think society in America is going to the shitters but it just breaks your heart when massmurder jonny gets the chair.
lmfao

See, the problem with you, and your morals, is that you see the massmurderer as nothing more than a massmurderer.  You neglect the fact that 1. He's a human being, being held in custody, and 2. There's a possibility he might be innocent, especially if he wasa just involved in one murder.

K, no more flaming from me, people have proven that they can't comprehend what I mean, and saying anymore will just get everyone pissed.
The problem with my morals? Can't comprehend what you mean? I know exactly what you're saying and I find it to be a bunch of idealistic bullshit. You seem to think if I see the issue from your own viewpoint that it would only be logical for me to agree with you.

Oh, and adding lol or lmao only makes you look ignorant. Especially when you are in the minority on this issue.

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard