QuestionMark wrote:
This exact notion is the very thing that lead to the events of the Holocaust. It started out with people not liking the supposed "Jewish Control" over their lives. It later transformed into hate, which in turn lead to the systematic killing of over 6 million. I regret to hear that there are still people out there who endorse such prejudice.
Israel is the ONLY beacon of democracy in the middle east and the sole representative of the west. I don't think Arabs hate Israel because of the so called "occupation" and such. What lies behind that hate is that the Arab leaders (such as Ahmadinejad) see Israel as a tumor, a dangerous thing that doesn't fit in the middle eastern environment. The winds of democracy and advancement are a threat to their regime, and so they do their best to fight it. Don't be mistaken, if a country like Iran was one of your neighbors, you can be sure they would find an excuse to hate you to preserve their theocratic dark-aged regime.
The support granted by the US government is driven primarily by American interest. The support resembles the one America has given the UK during WW2. They have actively supported UK to repel the Nazi advancment (and their crazy ideology) from reaching the last democratic outpost in Europe. Worldwide democracy is something the United States, as role model, is morally obligated to do.
1) Being opposed to Israeli government policy and to the influence Israel has on the US does not equate to supporting the abhorrent systematic destruction of 6 million human beings. I am correct that there are many rich and influential jews in the background of US politics - that is not something that can be debated. I was just commenting that they pack more of a political punch than they should based on the number of jews there are in the US as a percentage of the total population i.e. they have a disproportionate amount of control over US politics. This isn't some crazy conspiracy theory, it's just fact. i'm not suggesting they have some masterplan to destory us all or something.
2) Israel is a democracy yes. A democracy
for jews. I would call it an apartheid state or a jewish theocracy with democratic elements but not a democracy in its purest form. No other nation on earth guarantees citizenship to someone of a particular creed wherever they are in the world, further diluting the discriminated against minority.
I would disagree with you that the concept of 'democracy' in the heart of the middle east is what has caused such hatred amongst arabs in that region of the world. It is simply the fact that millions of people were unjustly displaced from their homes and left to drift into the wilderness. It is also the fact that the Haram-al-Sharif is now effectively under Israeli control. Humiliating defeats of arab armies at the hands of the Israelis means vengeance also plays a part in their hatred. Israel has not made one friendly overture towards any of its neighbouring countries since it came into existence in 1948 or any attempt to try and diffuse the tension in the region. It remains intransigent and steadfast, which is admirable in some ways, but further aggravating matters by settling more land that under international law does not belong to them is foolish and does them no good in the long term. I sometimes wonder - do Israelis want to make peace with their neighbours at all.
I will concede that Iran is a scary nation at the moment. The main reasons for hating Israel have now been supplanted with blind hatred that has been indoctrinated into arabs/persians from birth, which is not healthy and certainly does not lend itself to there ever being a comfy mutual co-existence between the two sides, which is a shame.
3) With your third point I have difficulty seeing Israel as a true democracy with proper democratic values. Also, Venezuela is a democratic nation yet USA seeks to undermine the democratically elected government, so US 'defence of democracy' is inconsistent at best. My belief, possibly wrong, possible right, is that the reason the US supports a country that is of so little strategic value is because Israeli money dominates US politics.
For the record. I believe in a two state solution to the Israel-Palestine issue. I do not want to see Israel wiped from the map. I do however seek justice for the Palestinians, people who are suffering their very own holocaust as we speak. They should be allowed to return to their homes in Palestine and be recompensed for the hardship they have had to endure.
Edit: Of course the original reason behind why the US strongly supported Israel stems from the Cold War. The likes of Syria and Egypt were backed by the USSR, Israel was USA's local henchman.
Last edited by CameronPoe (2006-06-14 09:33:37)