Announcement

Join us on Discord: https://discord.gg/nf43FxS
Discuss.
uziq
Member
+151|1622
i mean, the ancient religions are basically codified systems of 'be nice' morals and collective/community-based ethics that, applied correctly, can enable people to coexist peacefully with their neighbours and to give a structure and ritual to their everyday lived lives. irrational, certainly; but much in a complicated life that is valuable is (those hyper-rational societies planned according to the iron laws of Reason and History sure worked out well, didn't they boris?). centuries of philosophers and theologians studied a body of extant knowledge, shaped it, refined it, reasoned their ways through it. from it, we have much of the structure of our scholastic learning, our logic, and our metaphysics. aristotle, aquinas, augustine, ambrose, jerome, boethius, avicenna, averroes ... fichte, kierkegaard, nietzsche.

scientology was a franchise spinoff by one of the most prolific pulp sci-fi writers of all time, who literally announced halfway through his shoddy hack career that 'the real money is in religion' (i.e. tax exemption). it combined 1950s self-help manuals, upper east-side talking therapies, and a space opera. in all the thousands of pages of psychobabble and waffle, he didn't attain the clarity or insight of a single line from augustine's 'confessions'.

... but, yeah, they are basically the same thing. though i have no disagreement with you that religions can become "insane and horrible" forces.

Last edited by uziq (2019-04-12 02:23:09)

SuperJail Warden
Member
+188|1889

War Man wrote:

Should we even count Scientology as a religion?
No. If the founder of the religion is still in within living memory I don't think so. Give it a 100 years.
Shahter
Zee Ruskie
+282|4945|Moscow, Russia

uziq wrote:

i mean, the ancient religions are basically codified systems of 'be nice' morals and collective/community-based ethics that, applied correctly, can enable people to coexist peacefully with their neighbours and to give a structure and ritual to their everyday lived lives.
religions are nothing like that^. religions, all of them, are tools for establishing control, and nothing else. they can, by design, be used for anything - that's the problem.
if you open your mind too much your brain will fall out.
uziq
Member
+151|1622
cool bro. i read sam harris when i was 17 too. 2deep4me.
Jay
Bork! Bork! Bork!
+1,964|3528|London, England

Shahter wrote:

uziq wrote:

i mean, the ancient religions are basically codified systems of 'be nice' morals and collective/community-based ethics that, applied correctly, can enable people to coexist peacefully with their neighbours and to give a structure and ritual to their everyday lived lives.
religions are nothing like that^. religions, all of them, are tools for establishing control, and nothing else. they can, by design, be used for anything - that's the problem.
No, uzi is right, they are shared history and were built and refined as a way to share moral insights in the form of parables. The Bible is nothing more than written oral stories that were passed down as collective wisdom for centuries before someone finally put them down on paper. The same can be said for stuff like The Iliad and The Odyssey or any of the Norse myths.

The problems arise from when they were committed to paper because they lost their ability to evolve. Instead they became codified and worshipped as divine wisdom when in reality this was just a random endpoint.

Yes, religion can and has been abused but it wasn't created specifically to control or oppress anyone. It was meant as guidance.
"Ah, you miserable creatures! You who think that you are so great! You who judge humanity to be so small! You who wish to reform everything! Why don't you reform yourselves? That task would be sufficient enough."
-Frederick Bastiat
Shahter
Zee Ruskie
+282|4945|Moscow, Russia

Jay wrote:

Shahter wrote:

uziq wrote:

i mean, the ancient religions are basically codified systems of 'be nice' morals and collective/community-based ethics that, applied correctly, can enable people to coexist peacefully with their neighbours and to give a structure and ritual to their everyday lived lives.
religions are nothing like that^. religions, all of them, are tools for establishing control, and nothing else. they can, by design, be used for anything - that's the problem.
No, uzi is right
no, he is not. bullshit designed to fool people remains bullshit, regardless of how many moral values and shared history gets incorporated into it over years of practice. a logical system that has at its core a set of axioms some of which are false can be used to prove absolutely anything.

i've never seen a good augustine translation, but i've read a lot of tolstoy's stuff (which was fascinating and thought provoking indeed), still, no matter how many great artists find some form of inspiration in it, organized religion remains a control tool. i'm sure if scientology lasts as long as did christianity it will have its own shebang of augustines, tolstoys and the likes.

Last edited by Shahter (2019-04-13 07:32:00)

if you open your mind too much your brain will fall out.
SuperJail Warden
Member
+188|1889
People need to be controlled. I hold that as a plus for religion.
uziq
Member
+151|1622
in russia the orthodox church has always been a handmaiden to the autocratic state/ruler so it makes sense he has such an edgelord-skeptic view of religion. the church there indeed has helped to keep a giant population stupid and obeisant because of political reasons — vast territories with little possibility of military control, a huge imbalance in power and wealth, etc.

fortunately the world isn’t savage and barbaric russia.
SuperJail Warden
Member
+188|1889
Identity politics is boring. I read an online advice column by Slate. The old lady who ran it was very interesting and straight. She kept the whole thing diverse and interesting.

The new lady is a lesbian who decided she wanted to become a man one day. Now every other story is about bisexual, lesbian, gay or tranny problems. And even if the stories were repetitive it would be cool if the answers weren't too. Every suggestion of course fits in with the accepted PC narrative unfortunately. And it's all very boring.

That's the biggest issue with identity politics. It's all boring after awhile. I don't want to hear about LGBT shit all the time.
Shahter
Zee Ruskie
+282|4945|Moscow, Russia

SuperJail Warden wrote:

People need to be controlled. I hold that as a plus for religion.
if your point is that religion can be useful then i agree. the problem, as i said, is that it can be equally as useful for positive things as it can for negative.
if you open your mind too much your brain will fall out.
uziq
Member
+151|1622
which describes pretty much anything.
Shahter
Zee Ruskie
+282|4945|Moscow, Russia
uh-huh. reminds me of an anecdote:
a man to his idiot wife who has got another bottle of snake oil sold to her:
- dear, you are so easy to take advantage of! come on, what's the probability that you meet a live bear walking in the streets today?
- 50/50.
- what?!?
- i either meet one, or i don't.
if you open your mind too much your brain will fall out.
SuperJail Warden
Member
+188|1889

Shahter wrote:

uh-huh. reminds me of an anecdote:
a man to his idiot wife who has got another bottle of snake oil sold to her:
- dear, you are so easy to take advantage of! come on, what's the probability that you meet a live bear walking in the streets today?
- 50/50.
- what?!?
- i either meet one, or i don't.
Does this Russian joke end with him beating his wife while drunk? I know that is a thing with you people.

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2019 Jeff Minard