Dilbert_X wrote:
CameronPoe wrote:
Turquoise wrote:
Personally, I've seen that most Americans I know take a stance similar to my own in that they support the revolts, but they worry what government will take Mubarak's place.
Why would Americans be worried what takes its place? Is America a militarily weak nation bordering Egypt or something?? Are Americans averse to self determination and 'power to the people' in the context of a nation of desperate underemployed, underfed subjects of a kleptocrat, just looking for some bread and a job? Or is the real reason that they don't want true Arab sentiment electing leaders because the middle east is where a large percentage of the world's oil comes from and decades of mistreatment by western nations (backing brutal dictators/stooges, overthrowing democratically elected leaders, invading nations on shoddy grounds or simply 'in the national interest' (Suez)) has utterly alienated the Arab street from the west? That's not to say Arabs hate the west either. It may shock a lot of people to realise that they want all the things we have: TVs, iPhones, the internet, nice cars, good food, etc. Perhaps if we treated that part of the world with parity of esteem rather than viewing the region as 'peoples we must exert control over' we might foster better relations with them.
Oil price, Israel, nothing else.
except ~
Commerce, free trade, safe shipping lanes etc. If the region becomes unstable Who do you think will be policing it ? and no one will be bitching when we do.
Poe a good defence needs some depth to it in a modern world. Keeping your lawn mowed short around your house simply will not do anymore as a deterrent to surprise attack. Oil producing countries want to sell oil to Oil consuming countries. Why should Producers or Consumers let outside factions interfere ? The driving force is actually " that that they want all the things we have: TVs, iPhones, the internet, nice cars, good food, etc. " not a prehistoric subjugating ruling Class/religion that will beat them back down into serfdom and mistreatment by backing brutal dictators/stooges, which is what they will get ( See Iran )
Perhaps if
They treated that part of the world with parity of esteem rather than viewing the region as 'peoples
They must exert control over' we might foster better relations with them.
PS people who have TVs, iPhones, the internet, nice cars, good food, will be less and less likely to become uninformed mindless fodder in a religious war. It is from the poverty stricken areas where they recruit the most. They see this resource slipping away. That is one reason they are on the march.