The BF2s Arms Contract Contest! - Best SMG/PDW [Round 1-1A]

Pages: 1

Topic closed

Index »
Community »
Everything Else »
Polls »
The BF2s Arms Contract Contest! - Best SMG/PDW [Round 1-1A]

Poll

Best SMG/PDW [Round 1-1A]

Td18	30%	30% - 17
Ft20	69%	69% - 39
Total: 56

2009-08-16 22:12:06

Eagle: Togs8896 is my evil alter ego; +567|6848|New Hampshire, USA

The BF2s Arms Contract Contest! - Best SMG/PDW [Round 1-1A]

*note The sign-up thread is still open for submissions in other categories

This thread will remain open for votes until midnight the day after it is opened before being closed. In the event of a tie, the thread will enter sudden death and stay open until one vote is cast for either entrant.

Thread closes 17 August 2009 23:00:00 EST [18 August 2009 12:00:00 AM EST]

TD18

https://static.bf2s.com/files/user/14407/TD18%20SMG%27s.jpg

=======================================================================================================

FT20

https://static.bf2s.com/files/user/20895/myweapon%283%29.jpg

https://static.bf2s.com/files/user/14407/Sig_Pats.jpg

2009-08-16 22:16:29

SEREMAKER: BABYMAKIN EXPERT √; +2,187|6786|Mountains of NC

it would be hard to manuver with the mag so close to the grip on the TD

https://static.bf2s.com/files/user/17445/carhartt.jpg

2009-08-16 22:16:35

nickb64: formerly from OC (it's EXACTLY like on tv)[truth]; +77|5828|Greatest Nation on Earth(USA)

TD18: I could imagine feed issues from the mag at that angle/no ejection port???

FT20: No ejection port??? (I can't see one)/ not much for sights...

Neither looks particularly comfortable

=Null vote

2009-08-16 22:22:29

Noobpatty: ʎʇʇɐdqoou; +194|6571|West NY

nickb64 wrote:
/no ejection port???

FT20: No ejection port???

=Null vote

Wow wtf's up with everyone and all of these ejection port issues? We're not doing full blueprints of weapons, the port could be out of sight for christ's sake. That's a stupid thing to judge the weapons on.

First selection: Magazine wouldn't be in a comfortable place. If it were further from the grip then maybe a little breathing space would be permitted.

FT20: Looks like lining up sights with the stock in your shoulder could be a problem.
I will decide shortly...

2009-08-16 22:39:08

Karbin: Member; +42|6512

nickb64 wrote:
TD18: I could imagine feed issues from the mag at that angle/no ejection port???

FT20: No ejection port??? (I can't see one)/ not much for sights...

Neither looks particularly comfortable

=Null vote

Both COULD be the type that eject spend brass out the front, under the barrel.
I know there's a bullpup in 7.62 NATO that works that way.

2009-08-16 23:27:12

nickb64: formerly from OC (it's EXACTLY like on tv)[truth]; +77|5828|Greatest Nation on Earth(USA)

Karbin wrote:
nickb64 wrote:
TD18: I could imagine feed issues from the mag at that angle/no ejection port???

FT20: No ejection port??? (I can't see one)/ not much for sights...

Neither looks particularly comfortable

=Null vote
Both COULD be the type that eject spend brass out the front, under the barrel.
I know there's a bullpup in 7.62 NATO that works that way.

Even so...

Neither looks particularly comfortable to use.

2009-08-16 23:38:50

SplinterStrike: Roamer; +250|6628|Eskimo land. AKA Canada.

If I absolutely HAD to pick one of these, I'd take the FT20. Magazine on the first is a pain

Though I would rather a different gun.

2009-08-17 00:54:48

Ty: Mass Media Casualty; +2,398|6992|Noizyland

FT20. It's mean looking. The TD18 is cool and all but it has that silly-looking magazine sticking out in an awkward place.

[Blinking eyes thing]
Steam: http://steamcommunity.com/id/tzyon

2009-08-17 02:18:15

Ioan92: Member; +337|5940

Definitely the TD18. No only because its looks, but overall design.

I have always found that the MP5 magazine sticks out too much, this on fixes the problem greatly.

Adding to this, the FT20 doesn't even have a hand guard.

2009-08-17 06:59:35

.Sup: be nice; +2,646|6671|The Twilight Zone

TD18
nice design indeed!

https://www.shrani.si/f/3H/7h/45GTw71U/untitled-1.png

2009-08-17 10:37:05

[-DER-]Omega: membeR; +188|7044|Lithuania

TD18 should have won this one. The FT20 just looks too uncomfortable/unpractical on so many levels.

https://bf3s.com/sigs/fe717ed1eb823c939460a42f15bced7dd0057c51.png

2009-08-17 10:44:01

Doctor Strangelove: Real Battlefield Veterinarian.; +1,758|6686

One's an SMG.

The other is not.

2009-08-17 10:47:57

Ioan92: Member; +337|5940

Doctor Strangelove wrote:
One's an SMG.

The other is not.

PDW's are accepted.

2009-08-17 14:02:31

Ty: Mass Media Casualty; +2,398|6992|Noizyland

PDW is a very broad catagory. I mean I can use a shotgun as a personal defence weapon.

Edit: Actually forget I said anything, I was basing this on the fact hat the SM90 in another poll was accepted as a PDW.

[Blinking eyes thing]
Steam: http://steamcommunity.com/id/tzyon

2009-08-17 14:11:41

Doctor Strangelove: Real Battlefield Veterinarian.; +1,758|6686

Ioan92 wrote:
Doctor Strangelove wrote:
One's an SMG.

The other is not.
PDW's are accepted.

Fuck off, that thing's a fucking carbine. It's in fucking 5.56

Topic closed

Pages: 1

Index »
Community »
Everything Else »
Polls »
The BF2s Arms Contract Contest! - Best SMG/PDW [Round 1-1A]

Board footer

Jump to

BF2S Forums The BF2s Arms Contract Contest! - Best SMG/PDW [Round 1-1A]

Poll

nickb64 wrote:

nickb64 wrote:

Karbin wrote:

nickb64 wrote:

Doctor Strangelove wrote:

Ioan92 wrote:

Doctor Strangelove wrote:

Board footer