BF2S Forums Medics vs Snipers v2

Barrakuda777 wrote:

How is restricting our choice fair?

See this is what medics did last time, tweaked all the rules to suit them.

instead of taking 16 player size karkand, or 64 size tampa/zatar, lets take something that's good for both... like sharqi or mashtuur?

PrivateVendetta wrote:

What do textures have to do with it being a good map for infantry?
Karkand has 1 colour, seems to be quite popular.

there's almost no cover. have you ever done any serious infantry play on zatar map? let alone io?
it's meant for vehicles, like all carrier maps + tampa.

Last edited by hiberNative (2008-06-21 14:36:42)

hiberNative wrote:

PrivateVendetta wrote:

What do textures have to do with it being a good map for infantry?
Karkand has 1 colour, seems to be quite popular.

there's almost no cover. have you ever done any serious infantry play on zatar map? let alone io?
it's meant for vehicles, like all carrier maps + tampa.

Thats obviously besides the point completely.

Its pretty obvious that medics are the ones setting this up...

No offensive clays? Let them use the components of their kits in whatever way THEY SEE FIT, not however it convieniently falls into your agenda. I mean god knows theres gonna be some fag medic with a G36E running around, so snipers should be allowed to use claymores however the hell they want to also.

No picking up medic kits full health? Last I checked in a regular day of BF2, snipers are free to grab other kits for ammo/health and this is about proving snipers are worthless in game, so why not let them play how they normally would?

You can't pick both maps, and you sure as hell can't say that snipers can pick a map too, but not Zatar. The point is that you each can pick a map, you can't veto the other sides first choice, it doesn't work that way.

Keep it simple.

Unlocks allowed

You can pick up kits to use the advantages of the kit, but not the primary offensive weapon

each side picks a map - this cannot be argued against.

In event of a tie, you vote for a map, and play.

If a sniper kills a medic with a medic main gun, he must suicide instantly and vice versa.

Eh?

Barrakuda777 wrote:

Mint Sauce wrote:

pyscofrawg wrote:

Huge maps with a great view distance and not much place to hide? Sounds like a win to me.

Do you seriously want to be running around Zatar.

Tell you what. Pick any map but Zatar. Our choice is Sharqi.

Ok, we will choose another map, but you choose any map other that sharqi?

How is restricting our choice fair?

See this is what medics did last time, tweaked all the rules to suit them.

What? I'm picking Sharqi as our map choice..

Right, there seems to be some confusion over the rules, so I will set out the final rules, and they will not be changed.

* Clays can be used, but FF will be on.
* Snipers may not pick up Medic kits at any time, and vice versa.
* Unlocks may be used.
* Each team picks a map.
* Each round will last for 20 minutes, 2 rounds at each map. So match length is 4 x 20 mins.
* No glitching into buildings, or indeed the re-arming glitch.

I'm sorry to say this aswell, but if a Sniper picks up a Medic kit so re-health or revive someone, and indeed if a Medic picks a Sniper kit up to lob some nades or lay some skillbombs, then that particular player shall be excluded for the rest of the round.

hiberNative wrote:

Barrakuda777 wrote:

How is restricting our choice fair?

See this is what medics did last time, tweaked all the rules to suit them.

instead of taking 16 player size karkand, or 64 size tampa/zatar, lets take something that's good for both... like sharqi or mashtuur?

PrivateVendetta wrote:

What do textures have to do with it being a good map for infantry?
Karkand has 1 colour, seems to be quite popular.

there's almost no cover. have you ever done any serious infantry play on zatar map? let alone io?
it's meant for vehicles, like all carrier maps + tampa.

How about 16 player Dalian?

Btw..that clays with FF on will go so terrible bad! Can tell you that now. Half the tickets that the snipers will loose will be because of Tk's.

Last edited by RDMC (2008-06-22 10:07:13)

Who's in the medic team?

Sup i don't really have a team yet, but you are one person i want to play. And i'm setting this up so i decide the rules, these rules are fair to both teams as they are what kooda wanted anyway..

Snipers + claymores vs Accurate assault rifles + mass revive. Im betting on the ones that can heal and revive each other.

Miniman7474 wrote:

If Frawg plays his M95 will rape you all.

Fucker shot down my Z10 today on Wake! A clan member and I were raping Beach and as we went for repairs BOOM we blew up and Frawg had the kill with his M95.

I couldn't believe it!

I couldn't believe it either. It was more of an accident than anything.

Miniman7474 wrote:

If Frawg plays his M95 will rape you all.

Fucker shot down my Z10 today on Wake! A clan member and I were raping Beach and as we went for repairs BOOM we blew up and Frawg had the kill with his M95.

I couldn't believe it!

don't see why he'd use the inaccurate m95 when it's only effective against body armor. all bolt action rifles do the same damage against medics...