Excellent post, i defy any of the yes voters to argue with the common sense points made here.B.Schuss wrote:
I voted no. The size of the muslim community in europe is simply not significant enough to grant them enough voting power to change our societies through the democratic process. Let alone the fact that of the muslims living here, only a small ( ridiculously small ) minority is actually politically active.
They don't even have a political party to represent them. And I am not so sure they would want to change anything, even if they could. Most of them enjoy the secular life they can live here in europe, free to practise their religion as they see fit. None of the muslims I know would want to have scharia law in europe.
Also, europeans have fought too hard and suffered too much in the past to allow anyone to take away the accomplishments of liberalism, and democracy. The idea that we would allow muslims to do so is absurd, mildly put...
It is true that we are facing big challenges with regard to integration. It is also true that for too long, we have allowed the immigrants to live next to us without really getting to know them ( or wanting to do so ), and that we have allowed them to form parallel societies, knowingly or unknowingly. These are issues that need to be addressed, undoubtedly.
But we are not going to address them through isolation, or confrontation. These people don't present a threat, they present opportunities.
They are our fellow europeans, plainly put.
Certainly, the process of integration willl prove to be difficult. In some areas, compromises will have to be made.
But I am confident that we can achieve that without changing our legal system, or laws, or constitutions. Because that would be a compromise that I would be unwilling to make. And I don't think it has happened yet, or will happen at all.
Our identity is formed by our values, and the laws of the land. And those remain unchanged.
1. Muslims are a huge minority in terms of population.
2. Muslims have little or no significant political representation in terms of actual parties.
3. There is a lack of desire among European Muslims to even have Sharia law.
3. Effective integration is the key as opposed to appeasement or witch-hunting.
4. Europeans simply would not accept the surrender of their Western way of life.
Last edited by Braddock (2008-04-08 05:39:14)