BF2S Forums sailor testifies that marine commiteded a crime

: )


2006-11-02 11:12:02 +1 serious question good debate. thanks! ironchef

cuz it's fun, i vote we sticky!!!

IRONCHEF wrote:

So punishment for stealing lumber, is punishable by death of car by abrams tank?

Exactly correct sir. And what do you think the Iraqi's would do to an American looting during Marshal Law? Shoot them dead on the spot, that's what. Hey, at least you are beginning to understand what happened in that video, it's a start...

IRONCHEF wrote:

Mekstizzle wrote:

Yeah I agree, why the fuck should good soldiers die because of bad ones.

Lets just think about this, how many soldiers do you think have died because of a couple of bad soldiers ruining some Iraqi's life through stupid actions right up to the point where he starts agreeing with the insurgents and then plants an IED?

Edit: Above paragraph was kinda put bad but you get what I mean...

Are people actually defending these bad soldiers? In my eyes, they're traitors. If i was a soldier, i wouldn't really take kind to some soldier in-directly jeopardizing mines and fellow comrades lives. Cos that's what it is...

Exactly my point.  But since it was US SOLDIERS I was criticizing, who are diefied daily on this message board as infallable and for some reason automatically honorable or something...i get banned for wishing death on those "INDIVIDUAL BAD SOLDIERS" (had to say that so it doesn't get taken out of context by certain trolls here).  W/E.

alright, allow me to pose the rebuttal in "Ironchefese"

"So death of car by abrams tank, is punishable by IED?"

Last edited by kr@cker (2006-12-19 13:29:12)

kr@cker wrote:

IRONCHEF wrote:

Mekstizzle wrote:

Yeah I agree, why the fuck should good soldiers die because of bad ones.

Lets just think about this, how many soldiers do you think have died because of a couple of bad soldiers ruining some Iraqi's life through stupid actions right up to the point where he starts agreeing with the insurgents and then plants an IED?

Edit: Above paragraph was kinda put bad but you get what I mean...

Are people actually defending these bad soldiers? In my eyes, they're traitors. If i was a soldier, i wouldn't really take kind to some soldier in-directly jeopardizing mines and fellow comrades lives. Cos that's what it is...

Exactly my point.  But since it was US SOLDIERS I was criticizing, who are diefied daily on this message board as infallable and for some reason automatically honorable or something...i get banned for wishing death on those "INDIVIDUAL BAD SOLDIERS" (had to say that so it doesn't get taken out of context by certain trolls here).  W/E.

alright, allow me to pose the rebuttal in "Ironchefese"

"So punishment of death of car by abrams tank, is punishable by IED?"

If you were serving honorably in Iraq, and your squad members were considered no less than your own family, and they all died from an IED that was planted by a disgruntled iraqi man whose car was crushed by a US soldier acting like an ass, then hell yes, that offending soldier should have taken the IED blast himself for putting his fellow soldiers in danger.

Everybody has a right to live. No matter what they have done, it is not the situation where you put in the phrase "an eye for an eye..." they are human beings, just like the rest of us. And sadly, us human beings are sick pathetic shits half of the time. So deal with the fact that you are on earth and that people do bad things. That does not mean you have to "wish death on them", punished maybe, but death is a tad too much on my mind - and most other minds on this forum mind you.

Although you do have a point, you have to be balanced in these arguments and see where the "iraquis" , for example, are coming from. So I doubt you can reason to say that every soldier that fights in a war is automatically honorauble.

True.  I'm against the death penalty, yet I've wished death to corrupt soldiers.  Obviously I'd feel like shit if I heard those soldiers were actually killed by an IED in direct retaliation to their actions previously.  But yes, obviously, in truthful IRONCHEF desires, they should be locked away and made to think of the stupid shit they've done while attempting to perform the sacred and honorable duties of a professional soldier representing their country.

My apologies to the people who have posted constructively and have not delved in a world of their own spitting insults at each other.
This thread has gone far enough.
IT IS THE D&ST FORUM, BEHAVE
Although I am not going to take your pic away Fancy, I do not agree with the posting of it just to piss off/annoy/insult/hurt another member of the forums. No matter how many people think ill of him.

Closed