BF2S Forums American Soldier Abducted Tortured Killed

{USMC}Louis wrote:

Im sure that you would say the same if they flew planes into your country's buildings and you lost some of your family in the twin towers....Untill then you have no place to talk about reasoning...

I'm sorry for your loss IF you're telling the truth but the willful destruction of human life brought about by the Iraq war for both Americans and Iraqis does mean i have a place to talk....and talk i shall.

And don't get me started on CG's response.

Cerpin_Taxt wrote:

Funny how ATG's post exploded into this. One person posts something irrelevant, then another person addresses that, and so on. Before you know it, there's 10 pages of bickering that doesn't even relate to the OP.

You mean.....just like this one?!

Right and I dont doubt that but Iraq is part of it...I dont think all the motives for the war in iraq are right but they do have something to do with it..

m3thod wrote:

Any idea how to differentiate between a Saudi, Jordanian, Syrian, Iraqi or Iranian?

Check his passport and ask him.

Last edited by M.O.A.B (2007-05-28 10:47:30)

"LOL! There is nothing worse than being told that something that worked your nuts over is....crap! i'm loving it....guess who?"

i got that in a karma message and im assuming its from poor method....you are pretty sad buddy.

CameronPoe wrote:

I feel sorry for the soldier for the manner in which he was killed but if you're trying to tell me that Gitmo and Abu Ghraib are OK because of these barbarians acts then you can go jump. Two wrongs don't make a right. Both sides have commited atrocities in this conflict.

Sounds like you think they even themselves out. Personally I think no sleep and being naked in front of a camera while dogs barked at me is better than being murdered savagely.

CC-Marley wrote:

CameronPoe wrote:

I feel sorry for the soldier for the manner in which he was killed but if you're trying to tell me that Gitmo and Abu Ghraib are OK because of these barbarians acts then you can go jump. Two wrongs don't make a right. Both sides have commited atrocities in this conflict.

Sounds like you think they even themselves out. Personally I think no sleep and being naked in front of a camera while dogs barked at me is better than being murdered savagely.

Well it looks like someone like to assume a lot of things which are just not fucking true then doesn't it? What happened to the soldier is worse than what happens to those at Gitmo, far worse, but both are completely terrible and a stain on humanity.

Last edited by CameronPoe (2007-05-28 16:55:52)

m3thod wrote:

Deadmonkiefart wrote:

m3thod wrote:

The United Nations Convention against touture would be reliable if anyone would bother placing reliance upon it.

That was an incredibly obvious statement...
I don't see how it relates to what I said though.

Whats the point? Quote it from the popes ass if you want, no one abides by these pointless definations UN or no UN.

Yet again, it doe not relate to what I said.  I said:

Deadmonkiefart wrote:

It doen't matter what the dictionary says about the differences between tourture and interrigation.  Are you saying the definition in some dictionary is going to be more reliable than the United Nations Convention against touture?

I am surprised sometimes at how people look at human death in comparrison to other forms of retaliation..I dont understand why people get upset about taking detainees and making them stand naked in front of people..When not too long ago videos of soildiers getting their heads chopped off with a dull knife and being made to begg for life before they do it....Maybe in fact what they did in Abu Ghrab was wrong and certainly what they did was wrong but when US soldiers die war is war is the reason but when we humilate it is not said to be war is war...

{USMC}Louis wrote:

No im saying I would do anything to find out who did and that whole region is full of terrorists and they are more than likley involved

Terrorists which arrived after the US rolled in.

M3thod, don't bother with parker.  You know what they say about arguing with idiots.

Bubbalo wrote:

M3thod, don't bother with parker.  You know what they say about arguing with idiots.

Nice relevant post.

/fail

Stop wrecking my thread.

*(edit)
Thanks Lizzard!

Last edited by ATG (2007-05-29 08:52:54)

ATG wrote:

Body Found in River That of US Soldier
http://apnews.myway.com//article/200705 … GIO83.html

Hassan al-Jibouri, 32, said he saw the body with head wounds and whip marks on its back floating on the river Wednesday morning. He and others then alerted police.

Iraqis and terrorist know what happens when they are captured by Americans; they go to jail.
Americans know what happens if they get captured by Islamic militants.

I dunno about you but if China invaded my country and i would manage to capture one of them.. trust me he would not make it back to his base.  I would not torture him but for sure i would never let him go.. Im pretty sure you would do the same thing if some foreign nations decided to invade your country.