Braddock
Agitator
+916|6717|Éire
Should children be exposed to this kind of over-simplified, stereotype enforcing 'entertainment'? Discuss



Any Irish people (from either end of the political spectrum) a little offended by this?

Goooooo Planet!

Last edited by Braddock (2007-02-21 15:54:02)

CameronPoe
Member
+2,925|6982
Holy shit how did you even find that.....

Search criteria: Captain Planet Northern Ireland Sectarianism

???
Flaming_Maniac
prince of insufficient light
+2,490|7134|67.222.138.85
What? All Irish people don't throw Molotov cocktails at each other?
Braddock
Agitator
+916|6717|Éire
I would have posted it ten minutes earlier, but I was in too much shock! It seems to be completely un-doctored, that was a real episode of Captain Planet! I didn't know the lads up North had nukes, they didn't declare them during the recent decommissioning.

Last edited by Braddock (2007-02-21 16:02:47)

Turquoise
O Canada
+1,596|6832|North Carolina
LOL...  I don't know what's more disturbing...  the bad accents or the synth music.  *vomit*
HURLEY
Ima Crunchatize you.
+170|7109|The Lou
That was weird, I think it was supposed to be teaching a lesson though. lol
Varegg
Support fanatic :-)
+2,206|7237|Nårvei

I`m not Irish but i`m offended by the crappy quality animation, Cartoon Network is the buttsechs and my kids are not allowed to watch it

I`ll rather have my two 9 year olds watch LOTR before CN ....
Wait behind the line ..............................................................
fadedsteve
GOP Sympathizer
+266|6917|Menlo Park, CA
I cannot believe Captain Planet had this episode or was "okay'd" for release!!

That is a fucking kids cartoon for christs sake!! lol

I dont have any words to describe how inappropriate that is for children. . . how did that episode get past network executives and end up on a saturday morning kids program?? crazy. . .
PureFodder
Member
+225|6712
To be fair there are some wonderously um-pc kids cartoons if you go back far enough.
Doctor Strangelove
Real Battlefield Veterinarian.
+1,758|6895
Is this like a spoof of captain planet for people to laugh at?

And BTW has anyone else noticed that the earth guy in CP is from Africa?
Hurricane
Banned
+1,153|7057|Washington, DC

fadedsteve wrote:

I cannot believe Captain Planet had this episode or was "okay'd" for release!!

That is a fucking kids cartoon for christs sake!! lol

I dont have any words to describe how inappropriate that is for children. . . how did that episode get past network executives and end up on a saturday morning kids program?? crazy. . .
At least it mildly sort of explained the stupid fighting/terrorism in Ireland for me. Sort of.
CameronPoe
Member
+2,925|6982

Hurricane wrote:

fadedsteve wrote:

I cannot believe Captain Planet had this episode or was "okay'd" for release!!

That is a fucking kids cartoon for christs sake!! lol

I dont have any words to describe how inappropriate that is for children. . . how did that episode get past network executives and end up on a saturday morning kids program?? crazy. . .
At least it mildly sort of explained the stupid fighting/terrorism in Ireland for me. Sort of.
OMG. Please erase that silly memory from your head and do some reading.
Braddock
Agitator
+916|6717|Éire

Hurricane wrote:

At least it mildly sort of explained the stupid fighting/terrorism in Ireland for me. Sort of.
Get real mate! that's like trying to explain the middle eastern situation using a Venn diagram.
Hurricane
Banned
+1,153|7057|Washington, DC

CameronPoe wrote:

Hurricane wrote:

fadedsteve wrote:

I cannot believe Captain Planet had this episode or was "okay'd" for release!!

That is a fucking kids cartoon for christs sake!! lol

I dont have any words to describe how inappropriate that is for children. . . how did that episode get past network executives and end up on a saturday morning kids program?? crazy. . .
At least it mildly sort of explained the stupid fighting/terrorism in Ireland for me. Sort of.
OMG. Please erase that silly memory from your head and do some reading.
lol, I was half-kidding. At least it told me that two sects (right word?) of Christianity in Ireland hate(d?) each other's guts for some reason or another.

I always hated these kinds of TV shows. Let the education be done by teachers; TV is for learning the Way of Jack Bauer and the Wit of Dr. House. Maybe some Law and Order SVU, and American Idol for a lighter side of entertainment (its not THAT bad of a show...).

edit: There's karma for links to Wikipedia articles regarding teh terr0ristz.

Last edited by Hurricane (2007-02-21 16:16:56)

Not
Great success!
+216|7003|Chandler, AZ
Nobody's asking the important questions....how did they survive a nuke? Why did they have nuclear detonation friendship bracelets? And why did they walk around in the fallout with smiles on their faces?
scottomus0
Teh forum ghey!
+172|7064|Wigan. Manchester. England.
Fuck me ive not seen that programme for years!

But what the fuck was that episode!
CameronPoe
Member
+2,925|6982

Hurricane wrote:

CameronPoe wrote:

Hurricane wrote:


At least it mildly sort of explained the stupid fighting/terrorism in Ireland for me. Sort of.
OMG. Please erase that silly memory from your head and do some reading.
lol, I was half-kidding. At least it told me that two sects (right word?) of Christianity in Ireland hate(d?) each other's guts for some reason or another.

I always hated these kinds of TV shows. Let the education be done by teachers; TV is for learning the Way of Jack Bauer and the Wit of Dr. House. Maybe some Law and Order SVU, and American Idol for a lighter side of entertainment (its not THAT bad of a show...).
Well I'm atheist and I'm an Irish Republican - doesn't explain that. This is not a religious war - it isn't to do with religion - it's to do with another country having invaded and stolen our land and us trying to get them out and get our land back. Period. Religion is just a handy guide as to who is on what side.
Braddock
Agitator
+916|6717|Éire
That's a solution to the Iran situation. UN bracelet inspectors should be given access to search the wrists of all Iranians!
fadedsteve
GOP Sympathizer
+266|6917|Menlo Park, CA

CameronPoe wrote:

Hurricane wrote:

fadedsteve wrote:

I cannot believe Captain Planet had this episode or was "okay'd" for release!!

That is a fucking kids cartoon for christs sake!! lol

I dont have any words to describe how inappropriate that is for children. . . how did that episode get past network executives and end up on a saturday morning kids program?? crazy. . .
At least it mildly sort of explained the stupid fighting/terrorism in Ireland for me. Sort of.
OMG. Please erase that silly memory from your head and do some reading.
LOL! no shit!

Even though I think he was being sarcastic!!

Its unreal how they can disect a long conflict into a cartoon. . . my favorite part is at the beginning when he zaps the molotov coctail out of thin air!!! What a fuckin joke!! I mean out of all the conflicts Captain Planet sticks his nose into, he has to mess with the conflict in Northern Ireland??. . .tasty pick!!
Cheez
Herman is a warmaphrodite
+1,027|6865|King Of The Islands

What we need is nice wholesome cartoons like in the 30's

My state was founded by Batman. Your opinion is invalid.
BVC
Member
+325|7122
Might be an idea to watch the whole episode.

In that episode a mutant rat character called "Verminous Scum" comes up with a plan to start a world war, with the intention of causing a lot of radiation for another character called "Nukem" to bask in, eat, whatever.  He plants nukes in three troubled spots of the world at the time; South Africa, the West Bank and Ireland.  He then gives a remote trigger to someone on each side of the conflicts he is targetting, telling the people it will destroy thousands of people on the "other" side of the conflict; a black woman and a white male soldier in South Africa, a Palestian woman and an old Jewish guy in the West Bank, and two young men (a Protestant and a Catholic) in Ireland.

It then becomes the job of the planeteers to go to the hotspots and encourage the two people to resolve their differences, which they succeed in doing in all three cases.

You have to remember, Captain Planet was mean't to educate kids and promote peaceful/environmental causes, sometimes you just have to explain what nasty terms mean in order to do that.
Major.League.Infidel
Make Love and War
+303|6905|Communist Republic of CA, USA

Not wrote:

Nobody's asking the important questions....how did they survive a nuke? Why did they have nuclear detonation friendship bracelets? And why did they walk around in the fallout with smiles on their faces?
Because even though they have no qualms with making a cartoon like that, they don't want to draw in



WARNING GRAPHIC
(Mods - I'll remake them as links if requested)
























https://www.gensuikin.org/panel/10-1.jpg
https://www.gensuikin.org/panel/13.jpg
https://www.gensuikin.org/panel/10-2.jpg
Braddock
Agitator
+916|6717|Éire

Pubic wrote:

Might be an idea to watch the whole episode.

In that episode a mutant rat character called "Verminous Scum" comes up with a plan to start a world war, with the intention of causing a lot of radiation for another character called "Nukem" to bask in, eat, whatever.  He plants nukes in three troubled spots of the world at the time; South Africa, the West Bank and Ireland.  He then gives a remote trigger to someone on each side of the conflicts he is targetting, telling the people it will destroy thousands of people on the "other" side of the conflict; a black woman and a white male soldier in South Africa, a Palestian woman and an old Jewish guy in the West Bank, and two young men (a Protestant and a Catholic) in Ireland.

It then becomes the job of the planeteers to go to the hotspots and encourage the two people to resolve their differences, which they succeed in doing in all three cases.

You have to remember, Captain Planet was mean't to educate kids and promote peaceful/environmental causes, sometimes you just have to explain what nasty terms mean in order to do that.
That kind of 'education' does more harm than good, I shudder to think what they made of the Palestine Israel conflict. Political struggles as complex as those in Ireland, Middle East etc. should not be glossed over with such stereotype enforcing, superficial nonsense. If a subject like that is not gonna be treated seriously it should be left alone. Maybe kids shouldn't have politics fed to them in that way? ...There are books that cover these topics out there.
unnamednewbie13
Moderator
+2,072|7198|PNW

By your powers combined....
Fen321
Member
+54|6924|Singularity
wow..........i can't believe i watched that show. No wonder i want to hand out bracelets with Nuclear bombs waiting to blow up and cause harm to all my opposing sides. I got CP to thank for that!

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard