Karma is a good thing but it tells you who gave you karma.

2006-04-26 14:29:10

#1

cpt.fass1: The Cap'n Can Make it Hap'n; +329|6711|NJ

I'm hopefully not the only one to notice this, and I do like the karma system. But while reading topics lately it seems that people are giving karma then telling people they gave them karma. I know it's a new toy and pretty cool to let someone know that you agree with them. Put please for the love of something just limit it to giveing them the karma, don't post about it too.

it's basically like having sex with someone then just letting them know that you had sex with them.

Person one"hey we just had sex"
Person two "I know I was there"
Person one "well just letting you know that we did"
Person three from outside the bedroom window "I even know you just had sex"

Do you see my point thanks for the time

Last edited by cpt.fass1 (2006-04-26 14:30:31)

2006-04-26 14:31:15

#2

Kobrakai: Weirdo; +152|6804|England

Agreed, +1 to you.

2006-04-26 14:33:44

#3

SaladForks: /ph34r; +129|6597|Eastern USA

It's not at all like 'sex'. If you give them +1, then they might not notice it, or have so many karma that they seriously dont care (Wonder who I'm thinking of ). I'd give -1 for the negative insight, but +1 for the funny example.

2006-04-26 14:33:59

#4

khmer: Member; +86|6693|Central California

I like your analogy! LoL "hey we just had sex" +1 for you.

2006-04-26 14:34:36

#5

Varegg: Support fanatic :-); +2,206|6825|Nårvei

Kobrakai wrote:
Agreed, +1 to you.

lol

Well, not sure about u guys but i often have to tell my wife we just had sex, and as often she says WHAT ? ... can u prove it ?

Ah yeah baby, thats why i bought the camcorder ;-)

Wait behind the line ..............................................................

2006-04-26 14:36:48

#6

uber73: Member; +188|6767|Brisbane

karma sucks

2006-04-26 14:41:27

#7

King_County_Downy: shitfaced; +2,791|6613|Seattle

Varegg wrote:
Kobrakai wrote:
Agreed, +1 to you.
lol

Well, not sure about u guys but i often have to tell my wife we just had sex, and as often she says WHAT ? ... can u prove it ?

Ah yeah baby, thats why i bought the camcorder ;-)

Now that's funny!!!

/linky to video pls

Sober enough to know what I'm doing, drunk enough to really enjoy doing it

2006-04-26 14:42:25

#8

[NTHW]LemonyBrainAid: Karma whore; +27|6637

I think perhaps [like vB's rep system] once a user has reached 10 +karma they should be able to see who has karma'd them instead of everyone seeing everyone's. I also think there should be an option to enter a reason also :]

2006-04-26 14:56:16

#9

cpt.fass1: The Cap'n Can Make it Hap'n; +329|6711|NJ

No lemony that's a bad idea then as apposed to getting thought out messages about what you feel, they'll get thought out feelings about how cool they are. The reason would be your message you put after the post

2006-04-26 14:57:33

#10

WarmPudgy: Member; +41|6603|Arkansas

it also shows who gives you -1
ive noticed all the people that have given me -1 are people with like -70, and its the same ones every day

edit: never mind its ONE person that gives me -1 everyday
only 3 people have a positive karma, everyone else is negative

edit2: yay someone gave me +1, i love you!

Last edited by WarmPudgy (2006-04-26 15:01:41)

2006-04-26 19:03:43

#11

MooseRyder: Member; +37|6670|Montréal, Canada

karma is a toy like your saying and nothing else, its barely showing what people really think about you, because we got some kids here that give -1 to people for the hell of it, just to piss people off which i think its funny and kinda retarted.

oh and hey Tard if you read this i was kinda talking about you since your giving -1 everyday and keep it going, its cool to know someone actually think about me in these forums

2006-04-26 19:04:43

#12

Naughty_Om: Im Ron Burgundy?; +355|6648|USA

just for the sex inuendo you get +1...HEY I JUST gave you +1....

2006-04-26 19:12:45

#13

Spark: liquid fluoride thorium reactor; +874|6690|Canberra, AUS

I think the 'I +1'd you' is unneccesary. But sometimes if you neg someone, they might want an explanation, and its polite to do so.

Also, will there be a karma leaderboard (I doubt it somehow)?

Oh, better idea! How about, a page that lets you see who's been karma'ing and de'karmaing the most! That'll be the best way to catch trolls and spammers.

The paradox is only a conflict between reality and your feeling what reality ought to be.
^{~ Richard Feynman}

2006-04-26 19:16:11

#14

Naughty_Om: Im Ron Burgundy?; +355|6648|USA

speaking of the idea for REASONS for neg karma

go there... and read

http://forums.bf2s.com/viewtopic.php?pid=302890#p302890

2006-04-26 19:20:32

#15

strangelove: HOBO SPIRIT; +77|6636|the side hatch

+1 Secks!

Last edited by strangelove (2006-04-26 19:20:58)

2006-04-27 12:39:54

#16

kingusjordanus: Member; +16|6661|my dads balls

the karma system should have somthing like,

Last positive karma given by: that_one_guy
Last negetive karma given by: whiny_noob
or something like, at the bottom of the message, near the sig, it could say [username] gave +1/-1 karma to [other_username],

that might help a little. i dunno, just throwing stuff out there.
-kingus

2006-04-27 12:46:25

#17

cpt.fass1: The Cap'n Can Make it Hap'n; +329|6711|NJ

It's got that on the big thing by the search that says KARMA

2006-04-27 14:13:50

#18

Frizzley_Fry: Member; +8|6660

[NTHW]LemonyBrainAid wrote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AMD Athlon @ 2.0Ghz (2400+ ), 2GB Dual Channel RAM (@400Mhz), nVidia nForce2 (Soon to be A8V deluxe - When new processor arrives), ATi 9800 PRO (Soon to be something better... lol), Blue Neons with CoolerMaster Cavalier Case (Blue)

-1 don't care what you have and certainly don't care what you're going to have

2006-04-27 14:14:54