Uzique wrote:
lowing wrote:
Uzique wrote:
and like i said it's not 'ideological', i'm not being a contrarian little anti-american bitch. nor am i sympathizing with or deploring the death of a terrorist scumbag. i've even admitted earlier in this thread that the 'messy' and 'controversial' parts of this operation are, sadly and yet realistically, entirely predictable. it just wasn't going to be a textbook, perfectly-legal mission. it's osama bin laden. an exceptional case.
that said, with 'humanism' in mind and whilst we can discuss something of an 'ideal'... yeah, perhaps less drunken college kids cheering in the streets. our side are the ones that are meant to be civilized, advanced, democratic and respectful of human rights. how many times have members of this forum posted links to islamic protests or street-movements in a disgusted and dismissive tone? how many of you have looked down at flag burning and protest actions from the middle-east? yet it's somehow a big party and an excusable behaviour when its americans doing it on american soil. that doesn't float... and it's so much worse when america are the one's meant to be setting an example to the entire world. what happens when the interventionist state starts acting and displays public behaviour like the 'failed states' it intervenes in?
in all fairness to the comparison, no one in the states masses for protests against the ME or its people calling for the deaths of all Muslims. Compared to the "death to Americans" banter displayed in the ME, along with beheading videos and charred American bodies hanging from bridges or dragged through the streets. I do not think it is fair to discuss them as the same things.
this doesn't happen because the middle-east doesn't completely fuck with your country on a daily basis. the middle-east doesn't have a history of taking all the wealth out of your country and distributing it to foreign people whilst the majority of your population live below the poverty line. it's not comparable, at all. but we're missing the point a bit.
here, watch this... they're always enlightening.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9IgOVOPLTYI
I can not agree with a lot of what he says. A lot of the violence generated in the ME is Muslim on Muslim. We are trying to stop that as well as terrorism. It isn't that Islamic culture hates America and here is why, empathize. It is They hate everybody, including their own neighbors, and don't even really need a reason to anymore. Simply because their fathers and grandfathers and great grandfathers did seems good enough.
It isn't the Americans strapping suicide vests on children and sending them into the marketplace. Help is help regardless of religion and I think he puts too much emphasis on what the soldiers believe in. I mean schools are being built, who cares by who? DO you think the Americans would blow up a hospital because it was built by a Muslim? DO you think a Muslim extremist would blow one up because it was built by America?
The insurgents in that photo, do you think they would worry about the death of a child if it meant they could kill an American? Do you think an American would kill a child if it meant the death of an insurgent? It goes way deeper than simply walk in their shoes, and empathize. sorry