FEOS wrote:
Shocking wrote:
Well then, to paraphrase: the national security strategy which demands 11 carriers is completely unnecessary and ridiculous.
No. The national security strategy that demands 11 carrier strike groups (much more than 11 carriers) must be revised if we are serious about cutting defense structure in a responsible way. And doing so involves negotiations with allies worldwide, as it impacts their security interests, as well. What we no longer spend, they will have to.
I realise that there's much more to carrier warfare than just having a carrier.
I'm not advocating the view that the US should cut its defense budget in half from one day to the next, but there are certain parts of the national security strategy that
are ridiculous. You may argue it's based on rationale but I don't see the point and/or benefit in maintaining a military that has the capability to be involved in 4 if not 5 conflicts around the world simultaneously. After the cold war, the single biggest threat to world stability disintegrated and, logically, countries decreased the sizes of their militaries... except the US. The US decided to
increase spending for god knows what reason and now you have a blue water navy the size of all of the other 'world power' navies combined + more.
I seriously doubt that your nation continually increased the military's budget and size solely because foreign nations asked you to, actually, I seriously doubt foreign powers even asked for that. Pre-2001, I'm sure they haven't, after 2001, I'm sure they requested emphasis on unconventional warfare which doesn't include building or maintaining more carrier strike groups (that just being one, albeit large, aspect of your military's capabilities). Plus, unconventional warfare doesn't require an increase in the budget, just a switch in emphasis and it's actually cheaper too.
Oh by the way I remember you were reading a book on Subudai some time ago, what was it called? I've read some stuff about him and he piqued my interest in the Mongols.
Last edited by Shocking (2011-10-04 12:36:46)