why would you judge a producer on his live DJ sets? it isn't drum n bass. every song he makes isn't some boring 'DJ tool', meant to be deployed in the club. aphex twin's music is music to be sat back and listened to, as full album-length pieces. live sets are not representative of an electronic producers work, typically. in fact, 'performance' has always been an area fraught with difficulties and problems, because most electronic music - i.e. composition/production - doesn't translate well to live performance, in the same way a traditional band would. using analogue electronic equipment live on stage is extremely difficult - just think of syncing it all together, with one individual - and the alternative, digital, is pretty boring live. a dude with a laptop on stage. ok gj. aphex twin has been known to play live-sets using a food blender. 'live sets' are a different beast. they are not what he is about. you are understanding it coming from the relatively simple and predictable DnB background, where every new record put out is mostly comprised of 'belters' to be played by other DJ's to rooms full of gurning people. IDM, especially, is not dancefloor orientated. it's aimed at the bedroom environment more than the dancefloor/live-set. so, basically, just go check out some of his albums. every one is very different, and extremely accomplished in its own way.PrivateVendetta wrote:
So since we're linking to stuff, i need an expert to link me to a good Aphex twin set.
Then I can judge properly.
inb4youneedotseeitlive
although aphex twin is known for putting on some of the best live shows of any electronic musician, i really would just recommend his albums. they are intended to be listened to that way, not as 'woah! here's the drop!' live-crowd tools. he mostly does extremely avant-garde/experimental classical compositions now, using a remote live orchestra, or just face-bending visual shows, with some of the world's top visual artists. for e.g.
again, dilberp, i never knew you had this talent for musicology... have you considered becoming an avant-garde critic?So far it sounds like late 80s chillout lounge muzak.
very chillout.
there are many descriptive labels i'd give to IDM. it is an extremely varied and complex genre. 'chillout lounge muzak' are not three of them.
no it wouldn't. know why? because i'm not an idle passive consumer of music like you are. i go to record stores. i buy music. i join mailing lists. many of my friends are involved in the actual music scene - production, promoting, working in record stores, dj'ing professionally, (national) music journalism. i wouldn't be relying on the NME weekly top10 chart for my music taste. not everyone is as apathetic as you. even today in this hyper-digitized, super-convenient age, i'd still say roughly 30% of my musical acquisition and exploration occurs in the flesh, person to person. i support record stores. i much prefer the experience of "digging in crates", as jay talks about as if it's an antiquarian and victorian pursuit, more than i do surfing the latest specialist torrent archive. music is still a living thing to many people. just because modern ease is there, doesn't mean everyone is automatically relegated to the super-passivity of itunes and spotify. i don't even use half of these digital services. last.fm is the only one i use, because it appeals to the audio geek in me. you are condescending in the extreme about this - and all for the simple and foolish reason, deriving from a puerile psychology, that someone can't possibly be into something or be more knowledgeable about something than you. you try to relegate and diminish other people's interest in something you (quite evidently) know nothing about, so as to minimize the damage caused by your openly displayed idiocy. not cricket.Your playlist would be a lot shorter if you didn't have itunes, last.fm, youtube and torrenting to pick stuff up from but relied on swapping with friends and buying LPs on spec from reviews in NME
Last edited by Uzique The Lesser (2013-02-21 08:20:04)