Western-based Muslims - send them all back home?

2006-10-05 11:46:43

#1

CameronPoe: Member; +2,925|6809

So, here's an open question for everyone -

Should all muslims based here in western nations be repatriated back to the countries from which they themselves or their fathers and forefathers come from?

After making your choice please expound on the merits of and reasoning behind said choice, it's feasibility, etc. I feel a lot of people on this forum would genuinely like to see fellow countrymen and women, who happen to be muslim, expelled from their country. This is their platform to tell me why.

2006-10-05 11:49:08

#2

sergeriver: Cowboy from Hell; +1,928|7011|Argentina

No fucking way. No further explanations needed.

2006-10-05 11:53:13

#3

Shopvac: If it doesn't say shop-vac keep shopping!; +25|6794|Grand Rapids, MI

Get the fuck out of here. That's Bollox.

2006-10-05 11:53:52

#4

h_w_s_b: Member; +6|6671

i find it somewhat unfeasible to "deport all the immigrants" whether they be muslim or not. where is the line drawn? i'm an american, but am i american "enough" to satisfy joe-blow's opinion of me?

considering joe-blow would be the one in charge of deporting me, i sure hope i am.

2006-10-05 11:57:09

#5

IRONCHEF: Member; +385|6745|Northern California

An open question means it has room for more than a yes no question. But seeing this dumb question requires only one answer, no, then it's settled. How bout a new question/poll that encourages debate?

2006-10-05 12:05:08

#6

{BMF}*Frank_The_Tank: U.S. > Iran; +497|6832|Florida

Think about this question. If the U.S. did this, it would be no different than sending black people to Africa. Or sending white back to Europe. Its kind of a dumb question in my opinion. I have no problem with people living here that are muslim. The muslim religion itself isnt a threat to our country, its just a select mass of psychos that are a threat to us. Not really much different than the psychos here in the country that happen to be "Baptist Christians". They think God is killing our soldiers because we are being punished. The glass is half empty if you catch my drift. I for one, am not in the group of people you would expect to want muslims expelled from my country. My country is a mix of all ethnicities and religions. I dont mind it, so long as they are here legally.

2006-10-05 12:10:41

#7

Bertster7: Confused Pothead; +1,101|6835|SE London

Of course not.

I'm just surprised some people have said yes. If you start deporting muslims only that is blatant discrimination, if you take it further, where does it end. If the US and Australia were repatriated then the distribution of global population would totally fuck up.

Anyway, repatriating people based on race or religion never works. Look at Israel.

2006-10-05 12:13:01

#8

GunSlinger OIF II: Banned.; +1,860|6897

how about all religious people goto heaven RIGHT NOW and let the rest of us human beings sort out the mess.

2006-10-05 12:14:50

#9

GunSlinger OIF II: Banned.; +1,860|6897

aren't all of our ancestral homes located somewhere in Ethiopia

2006-10-05 12:17:52

#10

BVC: Member; +325|6949

I null voted.

They don't cause any trouble in NZ, but I'm told their behaviour makes them highly unpopular in many other western countries.

2006-10-05 12:18:04

#11

Bertster7: Confused Pothead; +1,101|6835|SE London

GunSlinger OIF II wrote:
how about all religious people goto heaven RIGHT NOW and let the rest of us human beings sort out the mess.

Sounds good to me.

A little unfair, but hey.

2006-10-05 12:24:14

#12

topal63: . . .; +533|6972

Lets see - hmm? I have Christian Friends, Jehovah's Witness Friends, Atheist Friends, Muslim Friends, Jewish Friends
AND NONE OF THEM ARE FANANTICAL NUTJOBS! Including the Muslim’s I know (and NO they are not secret Jihadists).

You’re judging a whole, from a part - and that does not make any sense at all.

Of course - I chose the “Go Fuck Yourself” option for framing a question in such an absurd fashion.

Think about the reality of the situation for a moment:

Here in America 15,000-16,000 murders happen every year. . .
About 40,000 thousand traffic fatalities per year (I think I read that somewhere?),
People are dying from Heart Disease - just because they are to freaken FAT.

Excluding the 9/11 tragedy (the full facts are buried and probably will remain so).
Excluding the brave that are an Occupying Force in another’s land.

How many Americans are dying at the hands of “Death to America” Jihadist’s Hands?
How many Americans are dying at the hands of Americans willfully and accidentally?

The real risk in life is not the hype of a “Terrorist” threat; it is more mundane or local.

National Security for America has always been Military Priority Numero Uno, prior to the hype and after the hype. I would simply like the nonsensical media-political hype to go away - not the Muslims.

Last edited by topal63 (2006-10-06 10:32:07)

2006-10-05 12:24:24

#13

ATG: Banned; +5,233|6783|Global Command

{BMF}*Frank_The_Tank wrote:
Think about this question. If the U.S. did this, it would be no different than sending black people to Africa. Or sending white back to Europe. Its kind of a dumb question in my opinion. I have no problem with people living here that are muslim. The muslim religion itself isnt a threat to our country, its just a select mass of psychos that are a threat to us. Not really much different than the psychos here in the country that happen to be "Baptist Christians". They think God is killing our soldiers because we are being punished. The glass is half empty if you catch my drift. I for one, am not in the group of people you would expect to want muslims expelled from my country. My country is a mix of all ethnicities and religions. I dont mind it, so long as they are here legally.

QFE

2006-10-05 12:44:05

#14

unnamednewbie13: Moderator; +2,053|7025|PNW

I gave on voting no after the 13th 500 internal server error in a row. Laters.

Last edited by unnamednewbie13 (2006-10-05 12:44:41)

2006-10-05 12:46:24

#15

golgoj4: Member; +51|7028|North Hollywood

{BMF}*Frank_The_Tank wrote:
Think about this question. If the U.S. did this, it would be no different than sending black people to Africa. Or sending white back to Europe. Its kind of a dumb question in my opinion. I have no problem with people living here that are muslim. The muslim religion itself isnt a threat to our country, its just a select mass of psychos that are a threat to us. Not really much different than the psychos here in the country that happen to be "Baptist Christians". They think God is killing our soldiers because we are being punished. The glass is half empty if you catch my drift. I for one, am not in the group of people you would expect to want muslims expelled from my country. My country is a mix of all ethnicities and religions. I dont mind it, so long as they are here legally.

Enough Said

2006-10-05 12:47:04

#16

SGT.Slayero: Member; +98|6719|Life in a vacuum sucks

Yes!!!

2006-10-05 12:48:37

#17

golgoj4: Member; +51|7028|North Hollywood

where are the 17%? Why are they not speaking up?

2006-10-05 12:53:30

#18

King_County_Downy: shitfaced; +2,791|6851|Seattle

If you have hate in yer heart, let it out.

https://www.uploadfile.info/uploads/dd8b6e2ddc.jpg

Sober enough to know what I'm doing, drunk enough to really enjoy doing it

2006-10-05 12:59:11

#19

OuTLaW667: Member; +2|6682

GO FUCK YOURSELF - Enuff said.

2006-10-05 14:06:34

#20

Miller: IT'S MILLER TIME!; +271|7009|United States of America

ATG wrote:
{BMF}*Frank_The_Tank wrote:
Think about this question. If the U.S. did this, it would be no different than sending black people to Africa. Or sending white back to Europe. Its kind of a dumb question in my opinion. I have no problem with people living here that are muslim. The muslim religion itself isnt a threat to our country, its just a select mass of psychos that are a threat to us. Not really much different than the psychos here in the country that happen to be "Baptist Christians". They think God is killing our soldiers because we are being punished. The glass is half empty if you catch my drift. I for one, am not in the group of people you would expect to want muslims expelled from my country. My country is a mix of all ethnicities and religions. I dont mind it, so long as they are here legally.
QFE

FTW!

2006-10-05 16:54:32

#21

DesertFox-: The very model of a modern major general; +796|6938|United States of America

I picked GFY. As long as they're legal immigrants into these countries, I have no problem with them.

2006-10-05 21:29:17

#22

kr@cker: Bringin' Sexy Back!; +581|6803|Southeastern USA

no, seems rather archaic, overreactive, and inhuman

but then i voted gfy as always, you should really re-think that option

Last edited by kr@cker (2006-10-05 21:36:18)

2006-10-05 21:33:00

#23

SuperSlowYo: slow as you go; +124|6814|Canaduhhh.. West Toast

most of the muslims ive met were really nice ppl... and i genuinely feel bad for em cause they arent allowed to eat pork... mmm pork, the other white meat

2006-10-05 21:35:06

#24

Masques: Black Panzer Party; +184|6976|Eastern PA

America's Muslims are something like 50x less likely to engage in radical activity like the Muslim populations of some European countries and are far more integrated into American society...why demogague them and practically ensure their radicalization.

2006-10-05 23:22:39

#25

Tetrino: International OMGWTFBBQ; +200|6984|Uhh... erm...

Miller wrote:
ATG wrote:
{BMF}*Frank_The_Tank wrote:
Think about this question. If the U.S. did this, it would be no different than sending black people to Africa. Or sending white back to Europe. Its kind of a dumb question in my opinion. I have no problem with people living here that are muslim. The muslim religion itself isnt a threat to our country, its just a select mass of psychos that are a threat to us. Not really much different than the psychos here in the country that happen to be "Baptist Christians". They think God is killing our soldiers because we are being punished. The glass is half empty if you catch my drift. I for one, am not in the group of people you would expect to want muslims expelled from my country. My country is a mix of all ethnicities and religions. I dont mind it, so long as they are here legally.
QFE
FTW!

O RLY?

Mostly, I agree. Deporting all Muslims will only make more radicals.

Yes	28%	28% - 41
No	37%	37% - 53
Go fuck yourself	34%	34% - 49
Total: 143

BF2S Forums Western-based Muslims - send them all back home?

Poll

GunSlinger OIF II wrote:

{BMF}*Frank_The_Tank wrote:

{BMF}*Frank_The_Tank wrote:

ATG wrote:

{BMF}*Frank_The_Tank wrote:

Miller wrote:

ATG wrote:

{BMF}*Frank_The_Tank wrote:

Board footer