unnamednewbie13 wrote:
Glad to know that you don't care if old people die. You're in good company with Jay, dilbs. Should I add that to the list of things you wouldn't bat an eye at if put into camps, like handicapped people, jews, roma, blacks, indian cab drivers?
Get more Australians vaccinated.
it's still not even clear to me on a utilitarian basis what exactly justifies the 'all of the young and healthy must shelter indefinitely to save the retired' thing. in a short-term emergency and a situation which is spiralling out of control, of course, shutting down society is the emergency-brake that we desperately need.
but why is it 'selfish' for your average working parent, or a 21 year fresh graduate, or a schoolchild, to mention their own interests, their own disrupted lives, their own suffering health, mental as well as physical, etc, in year 3 of the pandemic? why is it selfish for them to ask for an exit-strategy or clear plan? living under restrictions with remote learning, WFH w/ childcare, frequently closed small businesses, economic ruination, etc, indefinitely is a big ask when you cannot elucidate an actual strategy. IS it selfish at this stage for working-age or young society to start asking questions about the sacrifices they're making, when we seem to be stuck in an infinite loop or groundhog day?
without sounding too coldly ratiocinative, isn't it selfish for the least productive members of society, economically, socially, reproductively, etc, speaking, to keep asking for the rest of society to remain in permanent limbo so that they won't get sick? especially those who refuse stubbornly to get a vaccine despite clearly being at high risk, as years of data has amply confirmed.
an old person is 10,000x more likely to suffer serious illness or death than a 20-something. we need to discuss this rhetoric of the 'selfishness' of the youth. the people who seem most selfish to me, now, are the unvaccinated middle- and old- aged people. they will be the ones putting pressure on the hospital system and demanding life-saving care when their own idiocy lands them in an emergency. young people have 'done their bit', despite being basically at zero risk of harm themselves, for 2+ years. that sounds pretty selfless, to me.
Last edited by uziq (2022-01-05 03:25:06)