James-m
Member
+28|6566|England
EA supposadly do smotc for the best performing sgt major each month right? (im not sure who it is now) well, why dont they do the same for the best performing 4 star general each month and make him 5 star (general of the army i think?)

just a thought. dont grill me lol
0nehitkill
Member
+0|6547
EA doesnt give SMOTC to only sgt. majors, they grant it to whoever has the highest global score for the month. (or was it week?)
Talon
Stop reading this and look at my post
+341|6777
SMOTC doesnt exist any more. It was eliminated when officer ranks arrvied.
James-m
Member
+28|6566|England
ah what? that sucks ass. well i still its a good idea to have lol
d3v1ldr1v3r13
Satan's disciple on Earth.
+160|6702|Hell's prison
Army isnt the only branch with 5 star General/Admiral.
Noop-Ni
ROAR
+14|6515
But there isn't a 5 star General for the Marines, and since the ranks are Marine ones they won't have one.

LOGIC!
Leprechaun56
Proud Infantry Whore
+31|6600|U.S.A
5 star generals exist only in war time.
=MCHD= arush5268d
Member
+46|6518|Houston, TX
If I'm not mistaken, there's only been 2 5-stars in the history of the U.S.   And it's not for the U.S. Army only...other branches are eligible.
=REAPER[JAB]=
Member
+0|6503
No the Marine Corps are in the Department of the Navy-thus no five star-however the Navy sports the Fleet Admiral, the five star equivalent
CrazeD
Member
+368|6689|Maine
Because there is no 5-star General in real life...
Capt. Foley
Member
+155|6604|Allentown, PA, USA
No, there was a few 5 Stars.
Bradly
Eisenhower
Marshall
Nimitiz
Halsey
and a few others.
Not possitive on all of these but most of them where. Bradly was the last 5 Star when he died in the 1980s.
theknuck
It's pronounced Knuck, like in Knuckle!!
+45|6629|balls
mcarthur was too.....wasn't he???
DexterBelgium
Member
+3|6665
In US military:

Five star = general of the army

Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_of_the_Army_%28USA%29

"The second version of General of the Army, also known as a "Five Star General" was created by Public Law 482 of the 78th Congress, passed on 14 December 1944, first as a temporary rank, then made permanent 23 March 1946 by an act of the 79th Congress. This was done to give the most senior American commanders parity of rank with their British counterparts. (The acts also created a comparable rank of Fleet Admiral for the Navy). The second General of the Army rank is considered separate from the 19th century version and the two are not considered comparable.

The insignia for General of the Army, as created in 1944, consisted of five stars in a pentagonal pattern, with points touching. The five officers who have held the 1944 version of General of the Army were:
      •       George C. Marshall     16 December 1944
      •       Douglas MacArthur     18 December 1944
      •       Dwight D. Eisenhower         20 December 1944
      •       Henry H. Arnold     21 December 1944
      •       Omar Bradley     20 September 1950"

It hasn't been granted since, although (among others) Colin Powell was considered for the position by Bill Clinton.

"The rank of General of the Army is still maintained as a rank of the U.S. military and could again be bestowed pending approval of the United States Congress. If appointed, the rank of General of the Army would carry a pay grade of O-11. Currently, official U.S. military policy is that General of the Army, General of the Air Force, and Fleet Admiral are only to be used in time of war where the commanding officer must be equal to or of higher rank than those commanding armies from another nation."

Reason for creating it was the British concept of a Field Marshal, which was the wartime supreme commander (below the queen of course), and which is technically superior to a five star, which would have meant Eisenhower having to salute a Brit. Why not call it a Field Marshal too then? mmm maybe Marshal Marshall was not such a good idea? That last is just a rumor tho.

There is even a higher rank: "General of the Armies", which is equivalent to a six star:

"The rank of General of the Armies is a title used in the United States Army as a supreme military rank considered the equivalent of a six star General. The rank has only been held twice in the history of the United States armed forces." Once of those, was even a posthumous grant to G. Washington, just to make him the most general of all generals. Not really a normal rank.

This is an excerpt of wikipedia on the term "general of the army"
Timmay
Member
+0|6696|Michigan
Yeah, for the Marines it doesn't look like there is an equivalent to General of
the Army.  GotA only exists during war time.  This is different than General of the Armies, which is considered a 6-star General.  John J. Pershing and George Washington were the only two General of the Armies.  Taken from Wiki.

Currently, the Sgt Major of the Corps is John L. Estrada.

Last edited by Timmay (2006-07-25 23:24:45)

CrazeD
Member
+368|6689|Maine

Capt. Foley wrote:

No, there was a few 5 Stars.
Bradly
Eisenhower
Marshall
Nimitiz
Halsey
and a few others.
Not possitive on all of these but most of them where. Bradly was the last 5 Star when he died in the 1980s.
I mean there's no longer a GOA.
Hurricane
Banned
+1,153|6647|Washington, DC

SMotC is still used in BF2. The last one finally played a round of BF2 on 1.3 and he got promoted to Colonel. Next month the system should update to the next SMotC who will probbably, unfortunately, be another person who never upgraded to 1.2.

There used to be a scoreboard and probably BFHQ images for a 5 star rank, it was 5 stars in a circle. The 4 star General rank was diagonal 4 stars rather than a square. This was in 1.03 where they had the ranks:

Private to Sgt Major of the Corps
Second Lieutenant
Colonel
1 star general
2 star general
3 star general
4 star general
5 star general (probably the highest point general of the month)
EA (i think it was some special rank for EA employees that was never used, it was the old EA logo)
DICE (just like the EA rank but for DICE employees and with the DICE logo)
Anfidurl
Use the bumper, that's what its for!
+103|6609|Lexington, Kentucky
Well, the problem with thinking the Marines don't have a Five Star rank is that pesky "Department of the Navy" thing. The Marine would have to be beloved by the entire country, (or become a Naval officer after transferring from the Corps,) I'm guessing. See, why promote a Jarhead, when you could promote one of your own Sailors? That's the problem.
=REAPER[JAB]=
Member
+0|6503
Not totally, realize the Army created the Marines initially for defense of the ships from boarding actions and thus the fact they have Generals is a little amazing

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2024 Jeff Minard