RicardoBlanco
The English
+177|6570|Oxford
“Religion is an insult to human dignity. Without it, you'd have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things, but for good people to do bad things, it takes religion.”

-Stephen Weinberg.

Eloquent and true. Discuss?
=OBS= EstebanRey
Member
+256|6552|Oxford, England, UK, EU, Earth
100% correct, sir but let me add that it is also an insult to human life and the World we live in because religion dictates that God "made" us and the Earth which insults the reality that we are sooo privaliged to be alive in this World (consider all the events that had to happen)....
Cybargs
Moderated
+2,285|6718

=OBS= EstebanRey wrote:

100% correct, sir but let me add that it is also an insult to human life and the World we live in because religion dictates that God "made" us and the Earth which insults the reality that we are sooo privaliged to be alive in this World (consider all the events that had to happen)....
well thats a good conclusion

u do know that most wars were because of religion?
https://cache.www.gametracker.com/server_info/203.46.105.23:21300/b_350_20_692108_381007_FFFFFF_000000.png
Sydney
2λчиэλ
+783|6845|Reykjavík, Iceland.
Christianity has stomped into "our" heads that we are the best, Humans are the greatest race and the Earth is center of the universe.

Not true

Humans are the race that is going to destroy the earth one day, and the one that brings the most unbalance to nature, nature would go on unharmed if humans suddently got extinct

And the Earth is just a tiny piece of dust in the large solar system.
Cybargs
Moderated
+2,285|6718

PBAsydney wrote:

Christianity has stomped into "our" heads that we are the best, Humans are the greatest race and the Earth is center of the universe.

Not true

Humans are the race that is going to destroy the earth one day, and the one that brings the most unbalance to nature, nature would go on unharmed if humans suddently got extinct

And the Earth is just a tiny piece of dust in the large solar system.
you mean galaxy. earth is a pretty rock in the solar system.

if the chruch didnt banned galileos work then we might have made a lot more progress in science today... well we humans are the only species that have the power to destroy and protect all species on our planet
https://cache.www.gametracker.com/server_info/203.46.105.23:21300/b_350_20_692108_381007_FFFFFF_000000.png
joker3327
=IBF2=
+305|6600|Cheshire. UK
The problem with so many religions is that nothing is set in stone( forgive the pun, 10 commandments)
and as such with all the different versions they are open to your own interpretation.

For instance mulims....not picking on anyone here but the fanatics read the koran and come up with total different meanings than the " normal " muslims

Think pirate code!!!  " more a set of guidelines really "
topal63
. . .
+533|6720
Religion is responsible for the very fabric of society you enjoy today. . . it is probable that such structure is found in our mind and found in our genes even. War as well has helped produce many of the things found in society. Conflict & struggle has been responsible for much of the increase in man (that is - if you "believe" in the concept of progress).

The simplistic idea that belief in something unprovable or intangable; something transcendent - is not an insult - nor is it ugly. What is ugly is the most encouraged form of belief: blind faith in base immorality posing as morality in the name of God. To lump all forms into one bucket and mix (Buddhism, Hinduism, Sik, Gnostic Christian, etc.); and then denounce the whole of it is actually quite stupid.
Rygar
Canucklehead
+69|6648|Nova Scotia
Now, I'm not sticking up for religion, but isn't a thread like this the exact opposite and deserving of the same fate of the crazy guy's continual salvation ramblings (that are, rightfully so, closed and banned asap)?

edited for graid skool spelling

Last edited by Rygar (2006-06-09 05:57:06)

Spark
liquid fluoride thorium reactor
+874|6676|Canberra, AUS
So... where are JaMDuDe and his band of ignoramuses to 'counter' this statement?
The paradox is only a conflict between reality and your feeling what reality ought to be.
~ Richard Feynman
Cybargs
Moderated
+2,285|6718

Spark wrote:

So... where are JaMDuDe and his band of ignoramuses to 'counter' this statement?
i killed them all.

well most wars caused by religion are wars like "zomg u dont believe in my religion u should die lol" think of crusades.
https://cache.www.gametracker.com/server_info/203.46.105.23:21300/b_350_20_692108_381007_FFFFFF_000000.png
Rosse_modest
Member
+76|6777|Antwerp, Flanders

cyborg_ninja-117 wrote:

PBAsydney wrote:

And the Earth is just a tiny piece of dust in the large solar system.
you mean galaxy. earth is a pretty rock in the solar system.
No he means universe, since, as you are undoubtably aware, there are other galaxies than the Milky Way out there. But you are right about it being the prettiest pebble in our solar system. Too bad we have such a dull moon. Probably the most depressing place to live this side of the Milky Way's center.

Last edited by Rosse_modest (2006-06-09 06:03:06)

Spark
liquid fluoride thorium reactor
+874|6676|Canberra, AUS

Rosse_modest wrote:

cyborg_ninja-117 wrote:

PBAsydney wrote:

And the Earth is just a tiny piece of dust in the large solar system.
you mean galaxy. earth is a pretty rock in the solar system.
No he means universe, since, as you are undoubtably aware, there are other galaxies than the Milky Way out there. But you are right about it being the prettiest pebble in our solar system. Too bad we have such a dull moon. Probably the most depressing place to live this side of the Milky Way's center.
If you draw it to SCALE, then a 'piece of dust' in the SOLAR SYSTEM becomes a big overstatement. 'Molecule' is more accurate. Or 'Amoeba' - that holds true to the spirit of complexity.
The paradox is only a conflict between reality and your feeling what reality ought to be.
~ Richard Feynman
tip700
Member
+9|6625
while i partially agree, it is important to take note religion also has many positive contributions to human life. in times of struggle religion brought comfort to those who may not live to see the next day. religion brought about a means of control for society. like most things in life it has both positive and negative repercussions.
topal63
. . .
+533|6720
Well, this ignorant-man (me) has a fondness for all things mythical and those ideas that represent the symbolic and the transcendent.

There are humans that exist that are an insult to humanity (subjectively determined of course). . . and there are ideas that encourage them to exist in such a way. I see no proof that religion as a whole is an insult, but rather the opposite, the structure of being susceptible to mere suggestion (and not testing a “belief”) is a structure of mind. It is expression of the genome; the human design (designed by nature). Maybe your actually saying nature is an insult to humanity? To suggest that Stalin’s political-ideological  belief system (that killed 20-40 million of his own countrymen) is on par with Buddhism (or that Buddhism is an insult) is FUCKING ABSURD. Because the distinction (of form) is obviously not drawn correctly.
Cybargs
Moderated
+2,285|6718

Spark wrote:

Rosse_modest wrote:

cyborg_ninja-117 wrote:


you mean galaxy. earth is a pretty rock in the solar system.
No he means universe, since, as you are undoubtably aware, there are other galaxies than the Milky Way out there. But you are right about it being the prettiest pebble in our solar system. Too bad we have such a dull moon. Probably the most depressing place to live this side of the Milky Way's center.
If you draw it to SCALE, then a 'piece of dust' in the SOLAR SYSTEM becomes a big overstatement. 'Molecule' is more accurate. Or 'Amoeba' - that holds true to the spirit of complexity.
what he said.

earth is not a piece of dust in the solar system... pretty big rock, but in the galaxy its a piece of dust. and yes i do know there are other galaxies besides the milky way, u know what pulls all the stars in the milky way together? SAG A black hole
https://cache.www.gametracker.com/server_info/203.46.105.23:21300/b_350_20_692108_381007_FFFFFF_000000.png
topal63
. . .
+533|6720

RicardoBlanco wrote:

“Religion is an insult to human dignity. Without it, you'd have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things, but for good people to do bad things, it takes religion.”

-Stephen Weinberg.

Eloquent and true. Discuss?
No it is not an insult (nor eloquent, nor intelligent in conception) - it is the human counterpart (& naturally occurring structures found in man) that creates the indignity.

And more aptly it requires childlike acceptance of an ideology (any, non-religious as well) and the natural tendency (or learned tendency) for aggression & violence.
JaMDuDe
Member
+69|6779

spark wrote:

If you draw it to SCALE, then a 'piece of dust' in the SOLAR SYSTEM becomes a big overstatement.
No if u take a picture it looks more like a speck of dust

http://photojournal.jpl.nasa.gov/jpegMo … modest.jpg
King_County_Downy
shitfaced
+2,791|6599|Seattle

Religion is 99% demographic.
Sober enough to know what I'm doing, drunk enough to really enjoy doing it
RicardoBlanco
The English
+177|6570|Oxford

topal63 wrote:

RicardoBlanco wrote:

“Religion is an insult to human dignity. Without it, you'd have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things, but for good people to do bad things, it takes religion.”

-Stephen Weinberg.

Eloquent and true. Discuss?
No it is not an insult (nor eloquent, nor intelligent in conception) - it is the human counterpart (& naturally occurring structures found in man) that creates the indignity.

And more aptly it requires childlike acceptance of an ideology (any, non-religious as well) and the natural tendency (or learned tendency) for aggression & violence.
Without religion people would still know what is right and wrong (unless they were amoral). If a man committed an evil acts he would be called evil, and rightly so. Why then is it only under the pretext of religion that a good man can commit an evil act?

An example would be, say, the church burning witches at the stake. Blatantly evil and yet, under the pretext of religion, good.
Kaosdad
Whisky Tango Foxtrot?
+201|6680|Broadlands, VA
Again you are confusing the ideology (religion) and it's flawed implimentation by induhviduals.  The exact same thought process can be applied to almost anything from governments to operating systems.
RicardoBlanco
The English
+177|6570|Oxford

topal63 wrote:

Religion is responsible for the very fabric of society you enjoy today. . . it is probable that such structure is found in our mind and found in our genes even. War as well has helped produce many of the things found in society. Conflict & struggle has been responsible for much of the increase in man (that is - if you "believe" in the concept of progress).

The simplistic idea that belief in something unprovable or intangable; something transcendent - is not an insult - nor is it ugly. What is ugly is the most encouraged form of belief: blind faith in base immorality posing as morality in the name of God. To lump all forms into one bucket and mix (Buddhism, Hinduism, Sik, Gnostic Christian, etc.); and then denounce the whole of it is actually quite stupid.
Isn't it enough to see that a garden is beautiful without having to believe that there are fairies at the bottom of it too?
Shadow_Omega
Member
+16|6589

topal63 wrote:

Well, this ignorant-man (me) has a fondness for all things mythical and those ideas that represent the symbolic and the transcendent.

There are humans that exist that are an insult to humanity (subjectively determined of course). . . and there are ideas that encourage them to exist in such a way. I see no proof that religion as a whole is an insult, but rather the opposite, the structure of being susceptible to mere suggestion (and not testing a “belief”) is a structure of mind. It is expression of the genome; the human design (designed by nature). Maybe your actually saying nature is an insult to humanity? To suggest that Stalin’s political-ideological  belief system (that killed 20-40 million of his own countrymen) is on par with Buddhism (or that Buddhism is an insult) is FUCKING ABSURD. Because the distinction (of form) is obviously not drawn correctly.
just you wait until the only two religions left are buddhism and scientology,then the great war of 6704 A.D. will be the end of humanity.Xenu would be proud.
2ndLt.Tucker
If you can read this, your already dead
+33|6684|Stillwater, Ok
Before religion even came to be there were wars.  Nature has instilled a gene in every single organism to fight for survival. So often these conflicts are over land and natural resources and not so much Religion.  I dont recall WW1, WW2, Korean War, Vietnam War, Gulf War 1 & 2, 100 year war between france and britian, wars between spain and britain, Saxon invasion. Greek and Roman wars....hmmm funny all these seem to have occured from greed and well the original causes had nothing to do with religion.  The Crusades were yes but this is one of the few fought not because of religion....but over religous LANDS.  And again the words were manipulated by the literate and well literacy= power.
ksyme99
Member
+2|6662|Glasgow, Scotland

cyborg_ninja-117 wrote:

Spark wrote:

Rosse_modest wrote:


No he means universe, since, as you are undoubtably aware, there are other galaxies than the Milky Way out there. But you are right about it being the prettiest pebble in our solar system. Too bad we have such a dull moon. Probably the most depressing place to live this side of the Milky Way's center.
If you draw it to SCALE, then a 'piece of dust' in the SOLAR SYSTEM becomes a big overstatement. 'Molecule' is more accurate. Or 'Amoeba' - that holds true to the spirit of complexity.
what he said.

earth is not a piece of dust in the solar system... pretty big rock, but in the galaxy its a piece of dust. and yes i do know there are other galaxies besides the milky way, u know what pulls all the stars in the milky way together? SAG A black hole
Technically not, technically dark matter keeps the galaxy spinning, without it it would just fly away like using a blender without the lid on. And also technically, the stars aren't getting pulled together, the space between them is expanding so they are in fact growing further apart.

As for the religion crap, it is useless to have threads about this, you wither believe it or you don't, and it is very difficult to persuade someone otherwise. Religion brought around a lot of the structure and society we see today, it is part of being human to believe.
Agemman
Member
+9|6592
What I think is interesting is that the scientists have found the gene for "God"... In other means they have found the gene that makes us believe in a religion and not believe in a religion. Those that don't believe in any religion (like me) have a lesser portion of the gene. If we now know that religion have caused many wars and will continue to do so why don't we remove that gene? We wouldn't have any believes but probably a bit fewer wars.. Wouldn't that be good?

So what would you choose? Religion or a more peaceful world...

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2024 Jeff Minard