no, there really isn't. tolkien in academic circles is a god. not for his fantasy, of course. tolkien was one of the great old/middle-english scholars of our time, he has written absolutely seminal pieces of criticism on norse sagas and epics such as beowulf, and has studied their mythology to death. hence why it was so easy for him to invent an engrossing and believable 'legend' around middle-earth - he just re-used archetypal stories from old danish legends and whatnot. he was also one of the great philologists of the 20th century-- an academic discipline that is basically dead nowadays because of its intense difficulty and cross-displinal, comparative nature. i'd say tolkien was on par with nietzsche when it came to philology. his fantastic understanding of ordinary words and their etymological root is another strength he used in his fantasy: all those completely cohesive, working languages he invented? all stem from old-english germanic roots or indo-aryan forms. absolutely impeccable.
my tolkien professor was a direct student of tolkien's great proteges at oxford, marsden and shippey, so i kinda inherited a lot of her enthusiasm. tolkien studies, incidentally, are really fucking difficult. some of the toughest academic work i have had to do. old english is a real riot.
libertarian benefit collector - anti-academic super-intellectual.
http://mixlr.com/the-little-phrase/