Announcement

Join us on Discord: https://discord.gg/nf43FxS
Discuss.
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|5326|Argentina
Post here your reviews and scores for PS3 and X360 games.  The score system is from 1 to 10.  The games will appear in descendant order according to their average score in the OP.  It's better to read the reviews from real players than reading them from paid websites and magazines.  Please, don't edit an old post to add a new game, just make a new post.

PS3 GAMES REVIEWS:
GAMEREVIEWSSCORE
METAL GEAR SOLID IV: GUNS OF THE PATRIOTS89.9
LITTLEBIGPLANET19.5
MOTORSTORM: PACIFIC RIFT29.5
VALKYRIA CHRONICLES29.3
UNCHARTED: DRAKE'S FORTUNE79.1
NHL 0919
PIXEL JUNK MONSTERS29
PIXEL JUNK MONSTERS ENCORE19
RESISTANCE 219
ROCKBAND19
SOCOM: CONFRONTATION19
TEKKEN 519
RATCHET & CLANK FUTURE38.8
GRID28.75
TOP SPIN18.6
CALL OF DUTY 438.5
ELEFUNK18.5
FALLOUT 318.5
GHOST RECON: ADVANCED WARFIGHTER 218.5
MADDEN 0818.5
MADDEN 0918.5
MLB 0828.5
NARUTO: ULTIMATE NINJA STORM18.5
NBA '0818.5
RATCHET & CLANK FUTURE: QUEST FOR BOOTY18.5
GRAND THEFT AUTO IV88.4
HIGH VELOCITY BOWLING18.3
WARHAWK48.2
FIFA 0828
GRAN TURISMO 5: PROLOGUE58
MIRROR'S EDGE18
MOTORSTORM98
NBA 2K818
OBLIVION28
PAIN28
SKATE18
THE ORANGE BOX18
WORLD SERIES OF POKER: WAR FOR THE BRACLETS18
WORMS18
GUITAR HERO 337.8
FIGHT NIGHT ROUND 327.75
RAINBOW SIX VEGAS 227.75
TONY HAWK'S PROVING GROUND27.75
BURNOUT PARADISE47.5
NINJA GAIDEN17.5
TONY HAWK'S PROJECT 817.5
FRACTURE17
RESISTANCE: FALL OF MAN77
SONIC THE HEDGEHOG 217
ASSASSINS CREED56.8
CALL OF DUTY 326.75
ARMY OF TWO16.5
BATTLEFIELD: BAD COMPANY66.5
DEF JAM ICON16.5
HEAVENLY SWORD26.5
LEGO INDIANA JONES16.5
LEGO STAR WARS16.5
THE GODFATHER16.5
VIRTUA TENNIS 316.5
NASCAR 0916
TIGER WOODS PGA TOUR 0716
DARK KINGDOM15.5
HAZE25.5
SPLINTER CELL: DOUBLE AGENT15.5
NEED FOR SPEED PRO STREET15
THE SIMPSONS15
OVERLORD: RAISING HELL14
SPIDERMAN 314
TRANSFORMERS12.5

X360 GAMES REVIEWS:
GAMEREVIEWSSCORE
ROCKBAND19.75
NHL '0819.5
NINJA GAIDEN 219.1
BIOSHOCK39
GHOST RECON ADVANCED WARFIGHTER19
GUITAR HERO II19
MADDEN NFL '0919
MERCENARIES 2: WORLD IN FLAMES19
PGR419
ROCKBAND 219
MASS EFFECT28.75
BATTLEFIELD: BAD COMPANY58.6
BURNOUT PARADISE38.6
BURNOUT REVENGE18.5
COLIN MCRAE DIRT18.5
GUITAR HERO III18.5
HALO 388.5
NEED FOR SPEED MOST WANTED18.5
NHL '0718.5
ASSASSINS CREED48.2
RAINBOW SIX VEGAS 228.2
AMPED 318
FIFA 0818
FORZA 248
GHOST RECON ADVANCED WARFIGHTER 218
SKATE18
THE ORANGE BOX18
GEARS OF WAR57.8
GRAND THEFT AUTO IV77.8
CALL OF DUTY 467.75
LEGO BATMAN17.5
MADDEN '0817.5
NARUTO RAISE OF A NINJA17.5
NEED FOR SPEED PRO STREET17.5
RAINBOW SIX VEGAS27.5
ARMY OF TWO17
CRACKDONW47
LEGO STAR WARS17
LOST ODDYSEE17
MEDAL OF HONOR: AIRBORNE17
THE SIMPSONS GAME17
VIVA PINATA17
NBA STREET16.5
NFL HEAD COACH '0916.5
DEAD RISING16
MADDEN '0716
OBLIVION36
CALL OF DUTY 335.8
BATTLEFIELD: MODERN COMBAT15
FIFA '0715
BULLY SCHOLARSHIP EDITION14
CARCASSONE14
SAINTS ROW14
UNDERTOW14
SUPERMAN RETURNS13
ACE COMBAT 612
HEXIC HD12
PES 200812


Last post included: sergeriver

Last edited by sergeriver (2009-01-29 03:56:14)

Poseidon
Fudgepack DeQueef
+3,253|5106|Long Island, New York
Good idea. Would you mind if I made one for the 360 as well? Kinda seems weird to have one just for the PS3..

Burnout Paradise: 9.0
Grand Theft Auto IV 9.75
Motorstorm: 9.25
Obiwan
Go Cards !!
+196|5263|The Ville
Good idea but I use x play for this.
r'Eeee
That's how I roll, BITCH!
+311|5017

Resistance 8.5
Motorstorm 8.5
Uncharted 9.5
Rachet and Clank 8.
MGS4 10
GTA4 8.5
Miggle
FUCK UBISOFT
+1,407|5310|FUCK UBISOFT

Resistance 2
Rock Band 9
MGS4 10
BFBC 3
GT5P 6
Assassins Creed 7
Burnout Paradise 8
https://i.imgur.com/86fodNE.png
icecold2510
Member
+31|4862
These are all my opinions on the games I own. Do not get offended!

MGS4: GoTP  10
Great storyline, great gameplay. The online is fun. Many different weapons for different gameplay styles.

Motorstorm  8
Great racing game but no replay value. Online is fun.

Army of Two  6.5
Fun shooter but storyline is not so great and the game is short.
Online isn't all there either with connecting issues(haven't played online in a while so idk if EA fixed this)


Warhawk  8
Pretty good online only game.  Learning curve is long. Great battles though when you do know how to work the warhawks.


CoD4  9
Pretty good storyline. Great gameplay. Online is awesome. Ranking up could be improved...


GH3  8
Fun, same old Guitar Hero. Online is easy.  Songlist is
Replay value is pretty good if you want to challenge yourself on different levels(hard/expert)


GT:P  8
Great racing simulator. Has awesome graphics.  Not very long to complete.  Gets boring after a bit because of the same 3 or so tracks. Online is alright...

Pain  7.5
Single Player is fun for the first few hours until you beat it.  Theirs three different objectives you can do so you can keep playing after beating the main game.  Never tried 2 player yet though... It's pretty good for a PSN game.
[email protected]
Certified BF2S Asshole
+131|5024|The edge of sanity

Obiwan wrote:

Good idea but I use x play for this.
x play gives really shti reviews at least 50% of the time.
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|5326|Argentina

Poseidon wrote:

Good idea. Would you mind if I made one for the 360 as well? Kinda seems weird to have one just for the PS3..

Burnout Paradise: 9.0
Grand Theft Auto IV 9.75
Motorstorm: 9.25
Np.  I didn't include X360 just coz I don't have one but we could use the same thread if you like.
Poseidon
Fudgepack DeQueef
+3,253|5106|Long Island, New York

sergeriver wrote:

Poseidon wrote:

Good idea. Would you mind if I made one for the 360 as well? Kinda seems weird to have one just for the PS3..

Burnout Paradise: 9.0
Grand Theft Auto IV 9.75
Motorstorm: 9.25
Np.  I didn't include X360 just coz I don't have one but we could use the same thread if you like.
Cool. Perhaps get a mod to change the title to "console games reviews"? That'd be a bit better.

Last edited by Poseidon (2008-06-30 15:48:21)

sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|5326|Argentina
Gran Turismo 5 Prologue: 8.5, a traditional Gran Turismo game with better graphics and less cars.  A good choice while they release GT5.
Grid: 9, Awesome game.  Great graphics, speed and great money return, you will play it for hours.  A combination between Gran Turismo and NFS.  A very good choice for every car enthusiast.
Grand Theft Auto IV: 10, Excellent.  Amazing game.
Battlefield: Bad Company: 8, fun game, although graphics could be better.  I still need to play it more.
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots: 10, Excellent.  You don't need a review to buy this game.

Last edited by sergeriver (2008-06-30 17:29:01)

Poseidon
Fudgepack DeQueef
+3,253|5106|Long Island, New York
Ok well, here goes the 360 reviews:

Guitar Hero II: 9
Guitar Hero 3: 8.5
NHL '07: 8.5
NHL '08: 9.5
Gears of War: 9.5
Halo 3: 9.25
Bioshock: 10
Rock Band: 9.75
Call of Duty 4: 10
Battlefield: Bad Company: 9.25
Superman Returns: 3
Call of Duty 3: 5
icecold2510
Member
+31|4862

Poseidon wrote:

Ok well, here goes the 360 reviews:

Guitar Hero II: 9
Guitar Hero 3: 8.5
NHL '07: 8.5
NHL '08: 9.5
Gears of War: 9.5
Halo 3: 9.25
Bioshock: 10
Rock Band: 9.75
Call of Duty 4: 10
Battlefield: Bad Company: 9.25
Superman Returns: 3
Call of Duty 3: 5
I think you should make a separate thread so no one gets confused with the games  Or have a table...

Last edited by icecold2510 (2008-06-30 16:10:27)

r'Eeee
That's how I roll, BITCH!
+311|5017

Lmao, Miggle take it easy with the console shooters.
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|5326|Argentina

r'Eeee wrote:

Lmao, Miggle take it easy with the console shooters.
We just need to change the thread title.  Mods...
Poseidon
Fudgepack DeQueef
+3,253|5106|Long Island, New York

icecold2510 wrote:

Poseidon wrote:

Ok well, here goes the 360 reviews:

Guitar Hero II: 9
Guitar Hero 3: 8.5
NHL '07: 8.5
NHL '08: 9.5
Gears of War: 9.5
Halo 3: 9.25
Bioshock: 10
Rock Band: 9.75
Call of Duty 4: 10
Battlefield: Bad Company: 9.25
Superman Returns: 3
Call of Duty 3: 5
I think you should make a separate thread so no one gets confused with the games  Or have a table...
I'm presuming Serge requested for the title to be changed and it's now reflected in the OP.
Vilham
Say wat!?
+580|5335|UK
PS3

MGS4 10
Drakes Uncharted 9
RB6V2 8
GTAIV 9
Doctor Strangelove
Real Battlefield Veterinarian.
+1,758|5037
What's the point of having "9.4", wouldn't it be faster to rate the game out of 100 and give it a 94?
skipper2666
Go Canucks Go!
+13|4883|Canada BC
Crackdown -5-
nba street -6.5-
Halo 3 -9-
amped 3 -8-
Burnout Paradise -9-
Assassins Creed -8-
Oblivion -8-

All xbox 360 and all out of 10.

Last edited by skipper2666 (2008-06-30 17:51:36)

Machine_Madness
Madness has now come over me
+20|5005|Brisbane, Australia
for Xbox 360


CrackDown : 7.8
COD4: 8.9
Assassins Creed: 8
Halo 3: 9
BF:Bad Company: 9
Undertow: 4
GTAIV: 9
Vilham
Say wat!?
+580|5335|UK
lol u nab drakes uncharted is uncharted

also PAIN 8.5
Pixel Junk Monsters 9
Pixel Junk Monsters Encore 9

Last edited by Vilham (2008-06-30 18:26:33)

Phatmatt
Vroom Vroom
+298|4758|Canada

Just an idea, you should make a table. Would be easier to read and nicer.
A friendly suggestion
ELITE-UK
Scratching my back
+170|5043|SHEFFIELD, ENGLAND
PS3 Reviews.

Uncharted: 9
GTA4: 9
Motorstorm: 8
BF:BC: 7.5
GT5 Prologue: 9.5
Rathchet & clank: 9.5
GRID: 8.5
Call of Duty 3: 8
Lego indiana Jones: 6.5
Lego Star Wars: 6.5
Skate:8
HAZE:8

Last edited by ELITE-UK (2008-06-30 23:30:16)

warhero1
Eon8 failure:O
+12|5017
PS3 Review

GTA4: 9.5

Amazing game, great storyline and graphics though extremely overrated.

GT5 Prologue: 8

Good graphics, not too many cars as the full game but it's a  good hold over till GT5.

Resistance: 7

Alright storyline, pretty good graphics for being one of the first PS3 games.  Though the Chimera take quite a lot of bullets to kill..

Warhawk: 7.5

Haven't played it much online but it's pretty fun...no lag at all.  Warhawks are fun to fly...

Top Spin 3: 8.6

Good graphics, box says 1080P but only supports 720P so far.  Good gameplay, though the controls take a while to get used to.

Oblivion: 7.5

Alright graphics, haven't progressed through much of the game but it is fun to sneak up and kill random citizens:)

MLB 08: 9.1

Great graphics, deep franchise mode and good controls.  Best baseball game on PS3

Guitar Hero 3: 8

Good track list..online is pretty fun.  Overrated though.

Need For Speed Pro Street : 5

Good graphics, more realistic than previous NFS.  The game freezes up A LOT on my PS3 with the latest patch...

Assassin's Creed: 7

Good looking graphics, repetitive yet still fun to play as you progress through the story.  Not much replayability after completion though

High Velocity Bowling: 8.3

Uses SIXAXIS to bowl.  Good graphics, easy to pick up and play.  Good buy for only $9.99

Tekken 5: 9

Amazing graphics and great controls/gameplay.  Has online mode if you buy the bundle from the PS Store.

Last edited by warhero1 (2008-07-01 00:48:15)

sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|5326|Argentina
How do you do a table here?
Phatmatt
Vroom Vroom
+298|4758|Canada

sergeriver wrote:

How do you do a table here?
here you go
http://forums.bf2s.com/viewtopic.php?id=88705

Pretty much like making an html table.

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2020 Jeff Minard