Having played all three Smash Bros games extensively I feel that Melee is the most competitive thanks to numerous advanced techniques such as wavedashing and L-canceling. Because of this I voted for Melee, even though I mostly play Brawl these days.
The original Smash is not as well balanced as Melee or Brawl. Grabs are way OP, and there are really only a select few top-tier characters.
Brawl added a bunch of random elements to level the playing field, which is great for casual players, but frustrating for for skilled players.
The original Smash is not as well balanced as Melee or Brawl. Grabs are way OP, and there are really only a select few top-tier characters.
Brawl added a bunch of random elements to level the playing field, which is great for casual players, but frustrating for for skilled players.