-Sh1fty-
plundering yee booty
+510|5444|Ventura, California
BF2 - 9/10

The game was solid! The maps were very fun to play and I never got tiered of any of them. Each faction had vehicles that handled differently, weapons that had different stats, and there were 3 factions. That's a lot of unique gameplay for each faction and I liked how you had to adapt to your team's weapons and vehicles. The graphics were pretty good for it's time as well. I'm only making this a 9/10 because of the ridiculous amount of patching that would screw things up and add more bugs.

BF2142 10/10

It got everything right that BF2 didn't, and then some. My most fond gaming moments were spent on this game with my clan mates. The amount of hours put into this game is ridiculous. I loved the futuristic aspect of the game. It wasn't too far-fetched and it added a new level to the gameplay with the different vehicles like Battle Walkers and gunships. Don't even get me started on how awesome Titan was or I'll have to change my boxers.

BC2 8/10

Despite being a console port, which I remove 1 point for, it was a damn good game and it was fun to play! The game didn't have very many bugs and the patches didn't screw it up too bad. Overall I had a good experience. -1 for adding Rush, which was fun to play but overshadowed the crappy job they did on conquest which should have been the main game mode instead of rush.

BF3 8/10

From an xbox 360 perspective, there are almost no bugs whatsoever, and the game plays very well. -1 for bad maps, and -1 for terrible ranking and unlock system.
And above your tomb, the stars will belong to us.
13urnzz
Banned
+5,830|6467

dc combat 7/10

bf1942 42/10

bf2 2/10

bf2142 meh/10
=0_0=
::1
+2|4487
BF2 Modern Combat (360) 9/10
BF2 10/10
BF3 4/10
unnamednewbie13
Moderator
+2,053|6742|PNW

Battlefield 1942 - 9 - overall the best of the entire series, and that isn't just the rose-tinted glasses talking

Battlefield Vietnam - 8 - improved in some areas over 1942, but lost in others

Battlefield 2 - 9 - regarded by some as the pinnacle of the series, the comm-rose and the squad/commander VOIP and spawning system kept this game afloat for me. a series of terrible balance patches and community-splitting booster packs would've otherwise driven it down to a 6. to this day, I'll never understand why they nerfed the blackhawk but never the Mi-28, when that gunner's seat is just as rapetastic

Battlefield 2142 - 7 - truth be told, I only really played the demo. without the annoying 20th century ads on what's supposed to be a 22nd century game, I'd have liked it more. bought the game when it was on sale and installed it twice...just never gotten around to it

Battlefield BC2 - 6 - what the hell is this shit?

Battlefield 3 - 6 - the meh I got from single player and the inconvenient lack of steam compatibility has somewhat turned me off. I know multiplayer is a different experience entirely, but I just haven't brought myself to get heavily into it.
TehMyke
D:
+343|6679

Mutantbear wrote:

Bad Company - 11/10
Bad Company 2 - 10/10
Battlefield 2 - 2/10
banplz
robcr9
Member
+111|5951

TehMyke wrote:

Mutantbear wrote:

Bad Company - 11/10
Bad Company 2 - 10/10
Battlefield 2 - 2/10
banplz
Mint Sauce
Frighteningly average
+780|6256|eng

robcr9 wrote:

TehMyke wrote:

Mutantbear wrote:

Bad Company - 11/10
Bad Company 2 - 10/10
Battlefield 2 - 2/10
banplz
#rekt
eusgen
Nugget
+402|6763|Jupiter

Mint Sauce wrote:

robcr9 wrote:

TehMyke wrote:


banplz
aLi3nZ
Member
+138|6477|New Zealand
1942: 7/10
Desert Combat: 8/10
BF2: 9/10
2142: 5/10
BC2: 6.5/10
BF3: 8.5/10

Last edited by aLi3nZ (2012-01-23 04:59:41)

War Man
Australians are hermaphrodites.
+563|6684|Purplicious Wisconsin
1942: 9/10, would have a full 10/10 if they made it more assymetrical and each of the nations more unique. Road to Rome expansion was cool with the new vehicles and introduction of bayonets.

BF2: 7/10, Dice didn't keep their promises plus the commander wasn't done right. Dogfighting with airplanes wasn't as fun like it was in 1942.

BF2MC: 6/10, not that great. Its classes ended up coming back to BC1 in some form.

BF2142: 8.5/10, greatly improved over battlefield 2, was tons more fun plus the customizable classes were nice. Oh and the Titan game mode, epic fun.

BC1: 7.5/10, aside from 50 round Assault Rifles and a full auto M16a2, game was nice and the destruction really made it awesome

BC2: 7/10, changed some of the stupid things in BC1 to something better, also took another step into the unlock system. Recon class was real gay in this game plus the assault class having unlimited grenade launcher or c4 ammo was fucking retarded. Game was also less beginner friendly than before

BF3: 6/10, gone too far with the unlock system, game is even less beginner friendly than BC2 was. Most of the maps tend to be dull, plus not enough vehicles for my tastes.
The irony of guns, is that they can save lives.
Spearhead
Gulf coast redneck hippy
+731|6660|Tampa Bay Florida
1942 - 8.0.  By 8 I mean, a great game, but with some glaring issues.  Not nearly as fun as the first Call of Duty but the style of gameplay was definitely refreshing.

Vietnam - 8.5.  I enjoyed it probably more than BF1942.  The updated engine, gorgeous maps, improved infantry combat, choppers, music, etc. etc.

2 - 9.5.  Infantry combat was still not where it needed to be, but the vehicles were the best of any BF game, and the ranking system added longevity.  But what really made BF2 a classic was the squad/commander system. 

2142 - 8.5.  Vehicle combat was messy and not nearly as good as BF2, which took away a lot of the variety.  The unlock system was the best of all the BF's, and the infantry combat was the best as well.

BC1 - 5.0.  Horrible, it felt like Modern Combat.

BC2 - 8.5.  Something changed between 1 and 2, and 2 was absolutely amazing.  It was the first time I had played a Battlefield game on a console, and enjoyed it

BF3 - 7.0  Feels more like Call of Duty than an actual Battlefield game.

Last edited by Spearhead (2012-01-29 17:03:35)

Spearhead
Gulf coast redneck hippy
+731|6660|Tampa Bay Florida

Uzique wrote:

you're supposed to be rating the games you play, not the social experiences you have whilst playing them

why is gaming criticism and its critics in general so fucking retarded?
Because games in general are known for being popular with kids.  Who are generally immature, conceited, and not very skilled at intelligent discussion.
CC-Marley
Member
+407|6799
Battlefield 1942 - 10 (DC and FH rocked)
Battlefield : Vietnam - 8
Battlefield 2 - 9 (PR only last few years)
Battlefield 2 : Modern Combat - Never Played
Battlefield 2142 - 8
Battlefield : Bad Company - Never Played
Battlefield 1943 - Never Played
Battlefield : Bad Company 2 - 6
Battlefield 3 - 8

Last edited by CC-Marley (2012-01-29 17:28:13)

.:ronin:.|Patton
Respekct dad i love u always
+946|6779|Marathon, Florida Keys
Battlefield 1942 - 10
Battlefield : Vietnam - 9
Battlefield 2 - 10
Battlefield 2142 - 6
Battlefield : Bad Company - never played
Battlefield 1943 - never played this shit
Battlefield : Bad Company 2 - 3
Battlefield 3 - 3.5
https://i54.photobucket.com/albums/g117/patton1337/stats.jpg
gurdeep
­
+812|4725|proll­y
umad

also, Battlefield 3 - 3.5, urdoinitrong
.:ronin:.|Patton
Respekct dad i love u always
+946|6779|Marathon, Florida Keys
sorry IG nostalgia goggles glued to my face and they're never going to come off. its gotten to the point where i don't even enjoy current games even if im completely dominating at them because there's no learning curve at all. FPS aren't built around starting off having no fucking idea how to play and having to learn how to master the secrets of each little part until you are the very best. The most ive been able to do with bf3 is AN94+heavybarrel+RDS+forskingrip and i can take snipers at nearly any distance. On oman i went ontop of the construction building put a rifle scope on the an94 with a bipod and heavybarrel and i was autosniping everyone on the entire map at every flag. ended up like with 50-4 or something with some dude resupplying me. with a sniper assualt rifle. shit is fucking stupid.
https://i54.photobucket.com/albums/g117/patton1337/stats.jpg
gurdeep
­
+812|4725|proll­y
i dont enjoy bf3 nearly as much as bf2, but i still have fun with it. lower ur expectations or quit gaming
.:ronin:.|Patton
Respekct dad i love u always
+946|6779|Marathon, Florida Keys
yep and ill choose the latter
https://i54.photobucket.com/albums/g117/patton1337/stats.jpg
Roc18
`
+655|5761|PROLLLY PROLLLY PROLLLY

.:ronin:.|Patton wrote:

sorry IG nostalgia goggles glued to my face and they're never going to come off. its gotten to the point where i don't even enjoy current games even if im completely dominating at them because there's no learning curve at all. FPS aren't built around starting off having no fucking idea how to play and having to learn how to master the secrets of each little part until you are the very best. The most ive been able to do with bf3 is AN94+heavybarrel+RDS+forskingrip and i can take snipers at nearly any distance. On oman i went ontop of the construction building put a rifle scope on the an94 with a bipod and heavybarrel and i was autosniping everyone on the entire map at every flag. ended up like with 50-4 or something with some dude resupplying me. with a sniper assualt rifle. shit is fucking stupid.
You must've been playing with complete retards to go 50-4 doing that with the an94.
.:ronin:.|Patton
Respekct dad i love u always
+946|6779|Marathon, Florida Keys
its bf3 every server you go on you're playing with complete retards.
https://i54.photobucket.com/albums/g117/patton1337/stats.jpg
.:ronin:.|Patton
Respekct dad i love u always
+946|6779|Marathon, Florida Keys
fucking cod faggot migratory.
https://i54.photobucket.com/albums/g117/patton1337/stats.jpg
Roc18
`
+655|5761|PROLLLY PROLLLY PROLLLY
true lol
13/f/taiwan
Member
+940|5669

.:ronin:.|Patton wrote:

fucking cod faggot migratory.
i didn't know what "boosting" was until yesterday. now i know how to identify codfags.
BVC
Member
+325|6666
Battlefield 1942 - 10
Battlefield : Vietnam - 7
Battlefield 2 - 8.5
Battlefield 2 : Modern Combat - Never Played
Battlefield 2142 - Never Played
Battlefield : Bad Company - Never Played
Battlefield 1943 - Never Played
Battlefield : Bad Company 2 - 8
Battlefield 3 - 8.5
DrunkFace
Germans did 911
+427|6651|Disaster Free Zone

gurdeep wrote:

i dont enjoy bf3 nearly as much as bf2, but i still have fun with it. lower ur expectations or quit gaming
Worst thing to do ever!!

Anyone who does may as well just go get a lobotomy.

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2024 Jeff Minard